Marvel Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Due to hearing recent community feedback regarding Corellia and going back to Onderon I wanted to post this poll to see what map the community would rather use as our main map. We can remain on Corellia or we can return to Onderon if y'all want. Let us know! 1 1 Report Link to comment
Rohan Posted May 12 Head Admin Report Share Posted May 12 Clicked Onderon so fast 1 Report Current: Head Admin | Marshal Commander Link to comment
SUpER754 Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 WE NEED ONDERON BACK!!! Please, and thank you. 1 Report Current: 332nd Officer Major ARCL Jesse Former: Hardcase, Kix, 501st MEDL, Chief Medical Officer, Aviation Manager, Vice Admiral Tarkin Link to comment
Jayarr Posted May 12 Developer Report Share Posted May 12 I have bias I think 6 Report Link to comment
Comics Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 insane corellia even gets 1 vote over onderon The most fuckable person on Synergy Star Wars RP~ Link to comment
Juggernaut Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 if the trees are fixed in onderon then Im down for it otherwise +1 Corellia Link to comment
Jayarr Posted May 12 Developer Report Share Posted May 12 Just now, Juggernaut said: if the trees are fixed in onderon then Im down for it otherwise +1 Corellia What’s wrong? Link to comment
Rohan Posted May 12 Head Admin Report Share Posted May 12 Just now, Jayarr said: I have bias I think Rightfully so, please update Onderon with the suggestions if we get it back Current: Head Admin | Marshal Commander Link to comment
Danny1 Posted May 12 Veteran Admin Report Share Posted May 12 Onderon for life <3 Though Skybox for Corellia is so good gonna miss it. If Onderon could get a small update too that would be a blessing 2 Report Current: SPEC Regimental Commander Danny Former: Walon Vau, CG Commander Danny, Battalion Commander Fox Link to comment
-Xander Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) Onderons bcc sucks and corellia has more space for trainings including the 2 planets. Not to mention alot of documents gonna need edited again to be relevant to Onderon if we switch back and all the quests gonna need redone seems like alot of work just to please a few people Edited May 12 by -Xander 1 1 Report "I see. So, the mission was your usual version of success, then?" Fleet Admiral Yularen | CG SGM Price | Hunter Zero Link to comment
Bacta Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) i want anaxes v 3 it’s still the best map for SWRP Edited May 12 by Bacta 4 1 1 1 Report Link to comment
Juggernaut Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 2 minutes ago, Jayarr said: What’s wrong? so a lot of the trees are just super jank some have hitboxes way to big while others have none at all so it makes combat difficult Link to comment
Maverick Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Bro so many people made dupes for corellia already, what exactly prompted this? people dogging on the map? theyll start dogging on onderon if we go back daily just like they do every single map. endor crashs, anaxes is too big, titan base is too small. blah blah blah 2 Report Link to comment
LunarLucifer Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 EMAIL RECEIVED FOR SWITCHING BASES FROM SILVER I would personally like to go to onderon Link to comment
Jayarr Posted May 12 Developer Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, Juggernaut said: so a lot of the trees are just super jank some have hitboxes way to big while others have none at all so it makes combat difficult I’ve not heard of this, but it’s not surprising. I made them when I had little knowledge of collision models Link to comment
LunarLucifer Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 But most Trials for jed will be FUCKED for like consulars Link to comment
Juggernaut Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, Jayarr said: I’ve not heard of this, but it’s not surprising. I made them when I had little knowledge of collision models nothing against you Brother its just one of those little things and Dont get me wrong Onderon is great for its size but if we switch back its gonna upset a ton of pilots they love the sky box so if you can increase that as well I think you would win no contest. 1 Report Link to comment
Wulfram Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Have never clicked Onderon so fast in my life. Current; Delta 07 PVT Sev Previous; DS SUPL Tracer, "And he's supposed to be our demolitions expert?." Link to comment
Marvel Posted May 12 Author Report Share Posted May 12 This poll will remain up for a few days before any decision is made alongside the fact I'd like to remind people that change is never permanent! There is a large chance that after a bit on Onderon people start complaining about the map and we end up with another poll asking to go back to Corellia lmao. Nothing is set in stone! Also keep in mind we were on Onderon for years. There are still plenty of dupes that exist for it plus the void where any of your Corellia dupes will fit. Link to comment
Fyi Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 13 minutes ago, Jayarr said: I have bias I think Remake endor without performance issues pls 3 1 Report hi. Link to comment
JustTaco Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 6 minutes ago, Jayarr said: I’ve not heard of this, but it’s not surprising. I made them when I had little knowledge of collision models Just remake Endor ez 1 1 Report Link to comment
Crab_Shack Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Bring back Onderon ! Current: RC-3222 Omega Squad Private Atin Former: Rancor Private, 21st Commander, Cuy'val Dar Vhonte Tervho, Naval LT Dao Coruscant Guard CPT Thire, KU XO Charger Link to comment
Maverick Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, JustTaco said: Just remake Endor ez slow progress Link to comment
Joshua Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) I like both maps, however Corellia having two additional areas to teleport to for smaller events or Tryouts makes it slightly better imo. While Onderon had Sector 2 which was larger it was still the same Planet. It's a tough vote though. Edited May 12 by Joshua Link to comment
Jayarr Posted May 12 Developer Report Share Posted May 12 2 minutes ago, Fyi said: Remake endor without performance issues pls I liked the time period of Endor (when i was recon reg and marshal) but not the map itself Link to comment
-Xander Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 5 minutes ago, Marvel said: This poll will remain up for a few days before any decision is made alongside the fact I'd like to remind people that change is never permanent! There is a large chance that after a bit on Onderon people start complaining about the map and we end up with another poll asking to go back to Corellia lmao. Nothing is set in stone! Also keep in mind we were on Onderon for years. There are still plenty of dupes that exist for it plus the void where any of your Corellia dupes will fit. Only problem with this is every time we change map we need to edit documents to reflect the change and its a pain 1 Report "I see. So, the mission was your usual version of success, then?" Fleet Admiral Yularen | CG SGM Price | Hunter Zero Link to comment
JustTaco Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 2 minutes ago, Maverick said: slow progress Wait fr? Link to comment
Maverick Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, JustTaco said: Wait fr? personal project. i miss endor so much. Link to comment
Lyonaxis Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 I love democracy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1 Report Link to comment
Claire Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Onderon. But Hire a mapper to grab the actual base of Corellia and put it on onderon. And the actual interior of the Jedi temple Why? The current base allows for role play and extremely easy to learn. The Jedi temple is small enough for Jedi but big enough so it isn’t crowded. The outside/surface of Ondrron is great. Allows for RP opportunities and coreellia does not. 1 1 Report 41st Jedi Commander Luminara Unduli (Jedi Master) claire <3 Link to comment
Comics Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) Where were all these corellia defenders on the day it dropped cause there weren't many LMAO also crazy that people seem to only love endor when we're not playing on it Edited May 12 by Comics 1 Report The most fuckable person on Synergy Star Wars RP~ Link to comment
Jayarr Posted May 12 Developer Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, Claire said: Onderon. But Hire a mapper to grab the actual base of Corellia and put it on onderon. And the actual interior of the Jedi temple Why? The current base allows for role play and extremely easy to learn. The Jedi temple is small enough for Jedi but big enough so it isn’t crowded. The outside/surface of Ondrron is great. Allows for RP opportunities and coreellia does not. I'm geekin'. I never heard all this hate for the onderon base (the interior) when I was around, and I would have changed the base around if I did. Does everyone else feel this way? I think its an okay interior. I've made better to this day, but I don't think it's *that* bad Link to comment
Srama Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) I think we should go back to Onderon overall, I think it is a better map and just has a lot of things better than Corellia. Overall from my experience on Corellia, it has some better sim rooms than on Onderon on base. However, I will say I liked the environment and how much Onderon had over Corellia, and Onderon had a better village than the one on Corellia for the civilian factions. I would say though however, that the Jedi Temple on Corellia does look nicer however it misses a lot of things that actually make it functional, like a big training room instead of sharing it with everyone on base, and a holocron vault even though it not that big of a deal if we have a Holocron vault or not. However, almost or more than half the Jedi Temple has no-collide in places where it shouldnt be. Making it very easy and annoying to find people in it compared to the Onderon Temple which had a teleporter to base and none of it being no-collided. This last part is more on the crystal and hilt spawns being set up compared to actually how the map was made however, it is very easy to camp every spawn leaving it for one person to get all the crystal and hilt spawns compared to the Onderon map where it was almost impossible to camp every single spawn and were far spread out. Edited May 12 by Srama 1 Report Link to comment
Deathtiger Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 I like both maps but my biggest issue with Onderon is the space. both the Skybox and the map, the skybox is so small you can barely fly without hitting the Skybox but Corellia you have a larger amount of space to fly. If there was any way to get the Skybox increased on Onderon and other layers added to the map I think it would be great. Also, we just paid for this new map and have not even used it for a year. I remember when we switched to Onderon and no body liked it so we made edits to the map and made something we liked, are we not able to make edits to the map removing and adding things that we like/dislike to the map as we did with Onderon. 2 2 Report DEUS VULT Link to comment
Gears Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 11 minutes ago, Comics said: also crazy that people seem to only love endor when we're not playing on it "also crazy that people seem to only love any map when we're not playing on it" Fixed that for you 1 Report Currently trying to not be a forum gremlin Former Chancellor Palpatine | Former Yoda & Mace Windu | Former Shaak Ti & Anakin | Former Delta Squad Scorch | Former Mas Amedda | Former Director | Former Management Link to comment
shroud Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 marvel i love you for making this i hunter longest ahsoka (11 days) Link to comment
Ccmonty Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) you people are fucking insane. Onderon had so many issues, the skybox is really low, theres no where to build except under or above the map because of how many trees there are, hunting for crystals is unbearable because of the awful spawn locations, the grass in sector 2 being so high that it blocks your view and NPCs can hide in it, no cit meaning unless you want a sim in an empty room you HAVE to get a dupe spawned, drill pod spam during events because its impossible to get any enemy forces inside base otherwise, THE FUCKING TREE HITBOXES THAT BLOCK YOUR SHOTS. PEOPLE COMPLAINED ABOUT THIS FOR A YEAR AND NOW YOU WANT TO GO BACK TO IT?! WHY?! Give it a week and people will be BEGGING to go back to corellia. Also why hell do you want to replace the base???? the base and the temple are like the only good parts of the map Edited May 12 by Ccmonty 2 1 Report Link to comment
Bacta Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 This converation will be 1000x better if we actaully discuss pros and cons of the map instead of going off of vibes. 3 Report Link to comment
Claire Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 13 minutes ago, Jayarr said: I'm geekin'. I never heard all this hate for the onderon base (the interior) when I was around, and I would have changed the base around if I did. Does everyone else feel this way? I think its an okay interior. I've made better to this day, but I don't think it's *that* bad It’s not bad per say, it’s just such a huge base, and has a lot of people spread out leading to less RP, it’s not bad, but I think the current one is better. im not a huge god at hammer, I’ve only seen people do it and attempt a little to do myself, but would it be possible to like copy the current bases (with a few touch up’s to match the aesthetic of onderon)? 41st Jedi Commander Luminara Unduli (Jedi Master) claire <3 Link to comment
Mystic Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Where the hell was the Onderon love before? Shit was literally getting trashed on daily and we were at our lowest points ever. If we go back please go to V1/V2. V3 brought nothing but a laggy day to the server. Events were slideshows. This map is so much better optimized and actually feels like a base map. Onderon was just 10 inches of base and honestly felt like straight shit playing in after the base remodels. It felt so off. So non uniform. Patchwork base is what comes to mind. This Jedi Temple is BEYOND the best temple we’ve ever had. If we can swap the two then that is a gigantic W. I personally hate Onderon for being a walking simulator 2 2 Report Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Grand Master of the Order Yoda Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu Link to comment
Juggernaut Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 15 minutes ago, Jayarr said: I'm geekin'. I never heard all this hate for the onderon base (the interior) when I was around, and I would have changed the base around if I did. Does everyone else feel this way? I think its an okay interior. I've made better to this day, but I don't think it's *that* bad nah the base layout wasnt bad I think that everyone just likes having 6 sim rooms Link to comment
KaiserNeiner Posted May 12 Head Admin Report Share Posted May 12 I like Onderon more, yet voted for Corellia. I think both maps do something well, and if we could capture both then that would be ideal. The planets, interior of the base, and the Jedi temple on Corellia are superior. However, Onderon has a lot more open space for activities and it makes it a lot better for GM's, especially with the void. If GM's could get more creative and have better deployments, that would solve a lot of issues imo. We deploy maybe 7-14 times a week, and making THOSE more enjoyable and unique removes a bit of pressure off of GM's on Corellia to constantly host events that are mid. A rotation would be best. Get a Synergy Venator or another map, and cycle between 3 or 4 depending on the season of the year. 4 1 1 Report Kaiser Zeros Clutch Link to comment
Mystic Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 42 minutes ago, Jayarr said: What’s wrong? Please if we go back revert the base holy crap dude. V1/V2 were 20x better. Your first vision was correct. Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Grand Master of the Order Yoda Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu Link to comment
Kurt Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Where’s the option for Venator Extensive? I personally enjoy Coreilla, for the space to fly and build dupes. I just wish the Base was a lot more bigger like Onderons base or Anaxes v1 1 1 1 Report Current: Destiny 2 Sherpa | Human Hunter | Awoken Warlock | Exo Titan Former: Blackout x2, Jet x2, COE x2 Link to comment
ToasterBath Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 titan base bardan jusik Future Dev. Assistant Link to comment
Bacta Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Just now, Kurt said: Where’s the option for Venator Extensive? you woudl have went insane for synergy extensive 2 Report Link to comment
Mystic Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 3 minutes ago, Mystic said: Please if we go back revert the base holy crap dude. V1/V2 were 20x better. Your first vision was correct. @Jayarr a whole lot of the hate was happening post ban. It was when the server was falling off pre map update. 1 minute ago, Bacta said: you woudl have went insane for synergy extensive I think ours was Cydii. If you’re taking about the one Jayarr made. 1 Report Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Grand Master of the Order Yoda Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu Link to comment
Director Gohn Posted May 12 Director Director Report Share Posted May 12 Like a wise man once said. Put Corellia base on the Onderon map. Outside will be great, and the base will be great 10/10 1 Report Link to comment
Mystic Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 34 minutes ago, Jayarr said: I liked the time period of Endor (when i was recon reg and marshal) but not the map itself Also this. Endor was not a good map. Hot take. You miss the nostalgia and the shit that happened. 1 1 Report Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Grand Master of the Order Yoda Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu Link to comment
Ccmonty Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) 7 minutes ago, Gohn said: Like a wise man once said. Put Corellia base on the Onderon map. Outside will be great, and the base will be great 10/10 deforest onderon first IM RIGHT MARVEL THE TREES NEED TO GO Edited May 12 by Ccmonty 1 Report Link to comment
Brooklyn Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Just now, Mystic said: Also this. Endor was not a good map. Hot take. You miss the nostalgia and the shit that happened. I wish I could be mad at that statement... 2 1 Report Kal Skirata Bacta Marvel Brooklyn I beat Jad in a spar first try. Link to comment
Cointeer Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 10 minutes ago, ToasterBath said: titan base I agree with this statement Link to comment
Comics Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 12 minutes ago, Mystic said: It felt so off. So non uniform. Patchwork base is what comes to mind. There 3 stolen maps inside of corellia, there is literally a greasey republic commandos map outside of main base? how is that not patchwork but onderon is? The most fuckable person on Synergy Star Wars RP~ Link to comment
Jayarr Posted May 12 Developer Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) I've been sittin here trying to think of something to say, but the sudden hatewave for onderon is just a shock to me. I've got nothing to say to it. I wish I heard this all when I was around. All I got to see were a few server suggestions, no real complaints. They're not unwarranted, criticism helps any artist learn. I just wish all of this came sooner. Regardless, I'll take note of everything said here. I'm not certain if it'll matter for onderon or not quite yet, but I'll certainly take it all to heart for future maps. Edited May 12 by Jayarr 1 1 3 Report Link to comment
Baelfire Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 imo stay on corellia unless we can get the Onderon one revamped. I.E less trees, bigger sky box. just the TLC it needs. 3 Report Current Architect of Shadows Master Kit Fisto | Former Boss, Former Fixer, Former Sev Former Jaing, Former Prudii Former Bardan Jusik/Skirata Former SOBDE Regimental Commander Link to comment
Gears Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Onderon or Corellia your going to get the same Cookie Cutter Events, The Issue isnt the Map. Different Map, Same GM Team. 2 Report Currently trying to not be a forum gremlin Former Chancellor Palpatine | Former Yoda & Mace Windu | Former Shaak Ti & Anakin | Former Delta Squad Scorch | Former Mas Amedda | Former Director | Former Management Link to comment
Claire Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 11 minutes ago, Jayarr said: I've been sittin here trying to think of something to say, but the sudden hatewave for onderon is just a shock to me. I've got nothing to say to it. I wish I heard this all when I was around. All I got to see were a few server suggestions, no real complaints. They're not unwarranted, criticism helps any artist learn. I just wish all of this came sooner. Regardless, I'll take note of everything said here. I'm not certain if it'll matter for onderon or not quite yet, but I'll certainly take it all to heart for future maps. It isn’t bad. The map is great and the work you put in it shows. And for any other CWRP server it would be perfect! But the issue is trying to get more roleplay into the server and Onderon’s base is huge for something like that 1 Report 41st Jedi Commander Luminara Unduli (Jedi Master) claire <3 Link to comment
Brooklyn Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) I think a case should be made for both maps. I think the layout of Onderon is better, and has a way more expansive map, but Corellia has a lot better areas. I'll break it down for those of you who haven't voted Pros: Onderon Way better open map Locations are away from each other, but still accessible in short time Way more room for Dupes | Sector 2 | Void More space for Quests Not linear Synergy Exclusive Corellia Base is just a LITTLE better, layout wise Has a Citadel Has multi planets Slaver Camp as Neutral outpost is actually better than a Republic outpost Jedi Temple is insane Guild Hall is better than the Village HAS WATER Synergy Exclusive Cons: Onderon No Citadel Sector 2 is essentially useless and baron Base layout is elongated for little purpose Hitboxes on landscape really kill it Thesh is too massive for what it's used for. Would be better with defensive locations, and a door droids CAN'T shoot through Cave is neat, but too linear to have fun with 30% of the Village is used. The rest unfortunately (Cause I like the Village) is useless outside of bar and spawn BCC is in a terrible position Corellia Planets are only used for dupes, and Illum is the one used for 80% of tryout dupes, so a LOT of traffic delays Dark is nice, but would've done better with a swappable sky Literally a baron wasteland on top of base No flora at ALL besides the gmod trees Guild hall too accessible from base No void 1 actual SIM Room Events don't have as much flare, as GM's are working around claimed Planets, and a very linear map. Overall, Onderon outweighs the cons it has. Corellia unfortunately was a letdown for the stuff we were shown, and while it's a good map for a few reasons, it doesn't compare to Onderon and what it can offer. Anaxes V3 though is fucking fire. And since we have high pop again, why not add that to the poll. Edited May 12 by Brooklyn bcc plug 2 7 2 Report Kal Skirata Bacta Marvel Brooklyn I beat Jad in a spar first try. Link to comment
Ccmonty Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 2 minutes ago, Brooklyn said: Anaxes V3 though is fucking fire. And since we have high pop again, why not add that to the poll. +1 Link to comment
Joyboy Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 2 minutes ago, Brooklyn said: Overall, Onderon outweighs the cons it has. Corellia unfortunately was a letdown for the stuff we were shown, and while it's a good map for a few reasons, it doesn't compare to Onderon and what it can offer. Anaxes V3 though is fucking fire. And since we have high pop again, why not add that to the poll. This is Based Take #11 My time as Echo was shorter than Clutch's Yoda Term Link to comment
Banagite Posted May 12 Veteran Admin Report Share Posted May 12 I voted for Onderon mostly cause of the memories ngl but fr wish we could make a combination, that would be the best of both worlds in my opinion. From Onderon - Outside/Sector 2, Void, DB Room From Correlia - Sim Rooms/Planets, Skybox I could go for either base honestly, I loved the Onderon base heavily and to this day I heavily prefer Onderon's DB room. Corellia is a small base but like mentioned previously on this thread, it causes more interaction between players and we eventually got used to it being a small base. I think the outside of base on Corellia REALLY is the limiter on why people struggle to do really good outside base events/do anything outside base. On Onderon it didnt matter if you used a certain part of the map for tryouts cause there were so so many other places to be at. I have Bias for Onderon because its where I started this server and had my best times. 2 Report Current : Rancor BCMD Blitz | TRM | Questmaster | Veteran Admin Former : Obi-Wan Kenobi | Bultar Swan | Guild Marshall | Rancor CMD Colt | Rancor BCMD Blitz | Rancor Alpha-09 CMD Bana |SG WO Jayfon Link to comment
Marvel Posted May 12 Author Report Share Posted May 12 Okay even as a member of server management if you say you want Anaxes I can no longer guarantee your safety on this server 4 2 Report Link to comment
LIl-J Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 4 minutes ago, Brooklyn said: Overall, Onderon outweighs the cons it has. Corellia unfortunately was a letdown for the stuff we were shown, and while it's a good map for a few reasons, it doesn't compare to Onderon and what it can offer. Anaxes V3 though is fucking fire. And since we have high pop again, why not add that to the poll. This is another Based take part two +1 Link to comment
Claire Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Just now, Marvel said: Okay even as a member of server management if you say you want Anaxes I can no longer guarantee your safety on this server Anaxes is pretty cool 41st Jedi Commander Luminara Unduli (Jedi Master) claire <3 Link to comment
Brooklyn Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, Marvel said: Okay even as a member of server management if you say you want Anaxes I can no longer guarantee your safety on this server Guarantee your sanity before making the post Kal Skirata Bacta Marvel Brooklyn I beat Jad in a spar first try. Link to comment
Mystic Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 24 minutes ago, Comics said: There 3 stolen maps inside of corellia, there is literally a greasey republic commandos map outside of main base? how is that not patchwork but onderon is? 2 of the stolen maps are Bananakin’s. Reused assets aren’t stolen maps. The slave camp was because the map was supposed to be Trandosha but we named it corellia. It all fits. I meant on Onderon there were texture and color differences where pieces had been changed or removed. Looking like actual patchwork. You could tell it was renovated. It’s not even a bad thing. It was just a drop in quality. Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Grand Master of the Order Yoda Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu Link to comment
Arizona Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 54 minutes ago, Jayarr said: I'm geekin'. I never heard all this hate for the onderon base (the interior) when I was around, and I would have changed the base around if I did. Does everyone else feel this way? I think its an okay interior. I've made better to this day, but I don't think it's *that* bad please bless us with a bigger brig maybe with another floor? (;;;;; please jayarr bless us +1 onderon Link to comment
Rohan Posted May 12 Head Admin Report Share Posted May 12 13 minutes ago, Brooklyn said: Dark is nice, but would've done better with a swappable sky Sky & Sun editor work Current: Head Admin | Marshal Commander Link to comment
Brooklyn Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, Rohan said: Sky & Sun editor work Damn. Never seen it Kal Skirata Bacta Marvel Brooklyn I beat Jad in a spar first try. Link to comment
Mystic Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 27 minutes ago, Jayarr said: I've been sittin here trying to think of something to say, but the sudden hatewave for onderon is just a shock to me. I've got nothing to say to it. I wish I heard this all when I was around. All I got to see were a few server suggestions, no real complaints. They're not unwarranted, criticism helps any artist learn. I just wish all of this came sooner. Regardless, I'll take note of everything said here. I'm not certain if it'll matter for onderon or not quite yet, but I'll certainly take it all to heart for future maps. A lot of the downfall is not solely your part. The downgrade from V2 is a shared blame imo on whoever asked for it. A lot of this hate happened when you left. So don’t feel too bad about not hearing it prior. The lack of updates and whatnot killed the hype for Onderon since a lot of us saw it as a longevity project sort of like the Halo infinite campaign of synergy. Unique and meant to be updated over time to accommodate. Gears is right. The maps will change but the GM team won’t. There is a lot of issue with the events hosted that give maps a bad stigma. “Functionality boring blah blah” get thrown around a lot when our GMs aren’t creative enough to use the entire map or want to spam for quota. Onderon is one of the most unique maps in CWRP. It’s a good map. But I’m a V3 hater not a Jayarr hater. 1 Report Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Grand Master of the Order Yoda Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu Link to comment
Zeros Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 19 minutes ago, Brooklyn said: HAS WATER erm...onderon had 2 lakes i carried onderon events Link to comment
Brooklyn Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, Zeros said: erm...onderon had 2 lakes Doesn't quench my thirst. I need the DEEP DEEP water Kal Skirata Bacta Marvel Brooklyn I beat Jad in a spar first try. Link to comment
Zeros Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Corellia is like, actually the worst map I've been on (no offense to Bananakin). I've hated it from day one just because of how boring and lackluster it is. Onderon's base LOOKED better, had more space overall, and was just superior. Corellia has boring and restricting landscape, reused assets, two really mid planets, and no void. The only positive is the skybox but wah wah who really cares that much. Onderon still has ALL the old dupes which include my own. I will gladly disperse some into the wild for more variety in events. also onderon is my prime GM zone so fully biased. 1 minute ago, Brooklyn said: Doesn't quench my thirst. I need the DEEP DEEP water Corellia is only like trench foot level water! Sector 2 you could "drown" in! i carried onderon events Link to comment
Srama Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 hour ago, -Xander said: Onderons bcc sucks and corellia has more space for trainings including the 2 planets. Not to mention alot of documents gonna need edited again to be relevant to Onderon if we switch back and all the quests gonna need redone seems like alot of work just to please a few people Pretty much what you saying is you can either go grab some old docs or go back into edit history and get the old version of the documents or be use the Old Engineer Doc for the Onderon base if we go back. BCC is way better on Onderon than corellia in my opinion and I mean Onderon already had a lot of good quest and stuff sooo. Link to comment
Mystic Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 25 minutes ago, Brooklyn said: I think a case should be made for both maps. I think the layout of Onderon is better, and has a way more expansive map, but Corellia has a lot better areas. I'll break it down for those of you who haven't voted Pros: Onderon Way better open map Locations are away from each other, but still accessible in short time Way more room for Dupes | Sector 2 | Void More space for Quests Not linear Synergy Exclusive Corellia Base is just a LITTLE better, layout wise Has a Citadel Has multi planets Slaver Camp as Neutral outpost is actually better than a Republic outpost Jedi Temple is insane Guild Hall is better than the Village HAS WATER Cons: Onderon No Citadel Sector 2 is essentially useless and baron Base layout is elongated for little purpose Hitboxes on landscape really kill it Thesh is too massive for what it's used for. Would be better with defensive locations, and a door droids CAN'T shoot through Cave is neat, but too linear to have fun with 30% of the Village is used. The rest unfortunately (Cause I like the Village) is useless outside of bar and spawn BCC is in a terrible position Corellia Planets are only used for dupes, and Illum is the one used for 80% of tryout dupes, so a LOT of traffic delays Dark is nice, but would've done better with a swappable sky Literally a baron wasteland on top of base No flora at ALL besides the gmod trees Guild hall too accessible from base No void 1 actual SIM Room Events don't have as much flare, as GM's are working around claimed Planets, and a very linear map. Overall, Onderon outweighs the cons it has. Corellia unfortunately was a letdown for the stuff we were shown, and while it's a good map for a few reasons, it doesn't compare to Onderon and what it can offer. Anaxes V3 though is fucking fire. And since we have high pop again, why not add that to the poll. Should also note Corellia is also Synergy Exclusive 1 Report Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Grand Master of the Order Yoda Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu Link to comment
Zeros Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 51 minutes ago, KaiserNeiner said: Get a Synergy Venator or another map, and cycle between 3 or 4 depending on the season of the year. Boy do I have the map for you! (we made one and then abandoned it like months later because people hated the rotation) 52 minutes ago, KaiserNeiner said: If GM's could get more creative and have better deployments, that would solve a lot of issues imo. We deploy maybe 7-14 times a week, and making THOSE more enjoyable and unique removes a bit of pressure off of GM's on Corellia to constantly host events that are mid. I think the "7-14 times a week" is the core issue here. Focus on finding good GMs like we used to, run LESS deployments which means more time for quality rather than "WE NEEEEED MAX POP MAN CRANK OUT A SHOOT EM UP FOR 2 HOURS YEAHHH!!" type deployments. The map won't change deployments but Onderon definitely makes events easier with how modular it is (building dupes wise) like in Sector 2. 3 Report i carried onderon events Link to comment
Comics Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, Mystic said: Should also note Corellia is also Synergy Exclusive yeah not sure that would be an issue even if it was on the workshop 1 1 Report The most fuckable person on Synergy Star Wars RP~ Link to comment
Zeros Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 hour ago, -Xander said: Onderons bcc sucks and corellia has more space for trainings including the 2 planets. Not to mention alot of documents gonna need edited again to be relevant to Onderon if we switch back and all the quests gonna need redone seems like alot of work just to please a few people I can't even remember what Corellia's BCC looks like man. Isn't it just a straight line without any depth/feeling to it? Onderon atleast had never-working cameras. also naval yearn for doc work don't make it seem different i carried onderon events Link to comment
ninjakiller86 Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 yea lets bring back the old one miss the main elevator kills 1 Report Link to comment
Srama Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 2 minutes ago, Mystic said: Should also note Corellia is also Synergy Exclusive I think we also forgot for the pros on Onderon that it has a teleporter from the Jedi temple to the base. Also, I mean like I said before Corellia temple "LOOKS BETTER" however the functionality of it is something that needs to be improved on. I mean when the Jedi temple is almost or more than half of it isn't even actual props or is no collided its kind of wild. Link to comment
Banagite Posted May 12 Veteran Admin Report Share Posted May 12 Me Wanty Onderon 1 Report Current : Rancor BCMD Blitz | TRM | Questmaster | Veteran Admin Former : Obi-Wan Kenobi | Bultar Swan | Guild Marshall | Rancor CMD Colt | Rancor BCMD Blitz | Rancor Alpha-09 CMD Bana |SG WO Jayfon Link to comment
Brooklyn Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 7 minutes ago, Mystic said: Should also note Corellia is also Synergy Exclusive oof yeah i thought i added it for both 2 minutes ago, Srama said: I think we also forgot for the pros on Onderon that it has a teleporter from the Jedi temple to the base. Also, I mean like I said before Corellia temple "LOOKS BETTER" however the functionality of it is something that needs to be improved on. I mean when the Jedi temple is almost or more than half of it isn't even actual props or is no collided its kind of wild. I don't really see teleporters as a massive pro. Just an easy out 1 Report Kal Skirata Bacta Marvel Brooklyn I beat Jad in a spar first try. Link to comment
blazin Posted May 12 Head Admin Report Share Posted May 12 Onderon was way better. Sure Corellia is "prettier", but Onderon had way more functionality. Currently on base we have 1 real sim room, a citadel that barely gets touched, and 2 rooms so small that idk how they're counted as sim rooms. Sure the planets count, but when you can get kicked out at any point during a training or a tryout makes them annoying to use. Everything we have currently is just thrown on top of each other with no real care. Even when it comes to the Jedi temple, sure it looks better but with 0 sim rooms it just creates issues where Jedi have to go on Base and take those away from the Battalions. Have gotten countless complaints about Jedi holding up the on base sim room and there's just nothing I can even say. Also with Sector 2 on onderon, we had way more room to do GM stuff. That along with the void, Onderon was just 10x better fr. 1 1 Report Current: Palpatine Former: Shaak Ti | Arligan Zey | Kit Fisto | Luminara Unduli | Jedi Military Advisor | Null-10 Lieutenant Jaing | Null-6 Lieutenant Kom'rk | Bad Batch Echo | Bad Batch Hunter | Improcco Nye | Alpha-26 Maze | Walon Vau | Yoda x2 Link to comment
KaiserNeiner Posted May 12 Head Admin Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, blazin said: Onderon was way better. Sure Corellia is "prettier", but Onderon had way more functionality. Currently on base we have 1 real sim room, a citadel that barely gets touched, and 2 rooms so small that idk how they're counted as sim rooms. Sure the planets count, but when you can get kicked out at any point during a training or a tryout makes them annoying to use. Everything we have currently is just thrown on top of each other with no real care. Even when it comes to the Jedi temple, sure it looks better but with 0 sim rooms it just creates issues where Jedi have to go on Base and take those away from the Battalions. Have gotten countless complaints about Jedi holding up the on base sim room and there's just nothing I can even say. Also with Sector 2 on onderon, we had way more room to do GM stuff. That along with the void, Onderon was just 10x better fr. Hey can Jedi stop using sim rooms on base Mr. Yoda thanks 3 Report Kaiser Zeros Clutch Link to comment
Srama Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) 40 minutes ago, Brooklyn said: HAS WATER um, Ima just saying the Jedi temple on Onderon also had water. I don't see how Corellia's Water is a pro, but you do you. Edited May 12 by Srama 1 Report Link to comment
Charles Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 If you vote for Corellia consider yourself an opp. 2 Report Current: DSXO CPT Jek Former: 332nd Captain Vaughn | 332ndO Jesse | 332nd Vyse | TC Kano | 501st ARCO | Omega 22 Atin Link to comment
Gears Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Just now, Srama said: um, Ima just saying the Jedi temple on Onderon also had water. I don't see how Corellia's Water is a pro, but you do. Glorified Paddling Pool 1 Report Currently trying to not be a forum gremlin Former Chancellor Palpatine | Former Yoda & Mace Windu | Former Shaak Ti & Anakin | Former Delta Squad Scorch | Former Mas Amedda | Former Director | Former Management Link to comment
blazin Posted May 12 Head Admin Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, KaiserNeiner said: Hey can Jedi stop using sim rooms on base Mr. Yoda thanks Yea I'll just tell them to use the 5x5 closets behind bunks labeled "sim A" and "sim B" 2 1 Report Current: Palpatine Former: Shaak Ti | Arligan Zey | Kit Fisto | Luminara Unduli | Jedi Military Advisor | Null-10 Lieutenant Jaing | Null-6 Lieutenant Kom'rk | Bad Batch Echo | Bad Batch Hunter | Improcco Nye | Alpha-26 Maze | Walon Vau | Yoda x2 Link to comment
Charles Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 hour ago, Maverick said: Bro so many people made dupes for corellia already, what exactly prompted this? people dogging on the map? theyll start dogging on onderon if we go back daily just like they do every single map. endor crashs, anaxes is too big, titan base is too small. blah blah blah But everyone has their Onderon dupes saved... So I don't see the issue. Current: DSXO CPT Jek Former: 332nd Captain Vaughn | 332ndO Jesse | 332nd Vyse | TC Kano | 501st ARCO | Omega 22 Atin Link to comment
Danny1 Posted May 12 Veteran Admin Report Share Posted May 12 9 minutes ago, blazin said: Yea I'll just tell them to use the 5x5 closets behind bunks labeled "sim A" and "sim B" Just use your no-collided Pillars as SIM rooms :) Fr though half the temple is in the Ghost Zone Current: SPEC Regimental Commander Danny Former: Walon Vau, CG Commander Danny, Battalion Commander Fox Link to comment
Gator Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 (edited) Onderon Honestly Correlia feels confined, do what Kaiser said and make a map rotation throughout the year PLUS WE CAN GET A BIGGER MHB AGAIN Edited May 12 by GatorSkins Current: 212th Ghost Company MAJ Wooley Former: Ahsoka Tano, 501st WO, 212th REGA, 212th ARCO, 212th SUPL x3, Ghost Company XO/Lead Commander of Wooley Company Link to comment
Bananakin Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 y'all are cringe as hell 1 1 3 1 Report Link to comment
LunarLucifer Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Just now, Bananakin said: y'all are cringe as hell ehh. But I love your maps man Link to comment
Bananakin Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 Instead of yapping and complaining, post meaningful suggestions and ideas. Not "map stinks like toots and farts", legit helps nothing. This is literally like reading the workshop comments, hence why I turn that shit off. 5 Report Link to comment
DirtyDanLIT Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 1 minute ago, Bananakin said: Instead of yapping and complaining, post meaningful suggestions and ideas. Not "map stinks like toots and farts", legit helps nothing. This is literally like reading the workshop comments, hence why I turn that shit off. That's asking alot from some of these hooligans 1 Report Link to comment
RayRay Posted May 12 Report Share Posted May 12 How about hear me out, we got to a map thats not Either one of em. 4 Report Link to comment
Recommended Posts