Captain Keeli's Company

[Misfit]

Name: Misfit

RP Rank: Private

Suggestion: Add Keeli Company

Implementation: Keeli company has been a group talked about occasionally on the server. Some people ask "Why don't we add Keeli company" and then the discussion begins on "Why don't we add Keeli company?". The idea sometimes gets shot down with the statement that Keeli company was a sub unit of the 91st reconnaissance corps and if added could meet the same fate as the 91st its self along with 327th and 187th in the purge. Today im here to propose that Keeli Company actually gets added on to the Synergy clone wars server as a battalion in and of itself. Some people might argue that they only got one episode so they shouldn't be added. Dooms Unit only had one episode and look at how their battalion thrives day in and day out so why cant Keeli Company do the same. also for the commanders and things, do like you did for 21st and just ask some people to help build up the battalion.

Lore: https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Keeli https://clonetrooper.fandom.com/wiki/Keeli's_company https://clonetrooper.fandom.com/wiki/Unidentified_Keeli's_Company_clone_trooper_1

Workshop content if applicable:https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1940129729
(Require Development for the ARF trooper job or use this pack with no ARC trooper model  https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1687865339&searchtext=Clone+Troopers%3A+Keeli+Company)
(If no workshop content, suggest a developer or put "Require Development")

 

Edited January 15, 2021 by Corporal_Misfit

[Cubby]

+1

[Levii]

+1

[Cutlaw]

+1 +1 +1 +1, add Ima Gun Di alsoo 
For me Keeli holds a special place because of another interaction with the Company and it made me what I am today on SWRP and I would love to have them here aswell, you will get a dedicated member right from the get-go :)
Also  I know there will be things like we dont need more batts/regiments/companies, so I doubt this will get added

Youve got my full support tho


Edit: This was an easy prediction

Edited January 15, 2021 by Cutlaw

[Bacta]

-1 no need to add a new battalion, rather have more people in less battalions than have the community super spread out.  ESP rn with some battalions struggling rather focus on the current battalions.

Also Keeli company is super irrelevant in the entirety of the clone wars, they were wiped out in 1 battle in phase 1.

Edited January 15, 2021 by Bacta

[Bleach]

Maybe instead of adding new battalions

FIX THE CURRENT ONES

-1

[Nova_]

All right all right so I’m kind of skeptical if I should minus or plus one this I feel like there are things that should be taken into consideration first, So my main thing is that his who on this server would be the bcmd and how would this battalion get setup ?

Edit: So after looking at others comments and making my decision im gonna -1 this. I think it is a bad time for a new battalion and I think before any new battalion is added we need to have all battalion at a good place , But I would definitely +1 this if this was a  suggestion to add a bodygrouper for the event clone job for a Keeli company trooper

Edited January 15, 2021 by Nova_

[Zin]

I'm not sure if this is a great idea, first off. How would this battalion be implemented into the server? 

[Crimson]

My opinion, The server on a good day always has one battalion suffering from numbers or consistency. If it was a battalion switch I could see the argument but personally I am against it despite their one episode, DU at least had something if minor something special about them. 

 

-1

[Cutlaw]

9 minutes ago, Nova_ said:

All right all right so I’m kind of skeptical if I should minus on your pleasure on this I feel like there are things that should be taken into consideration first, So my main thing is that his who on this server would be the bcmd and how would this battalion get setup ?

Well, I want to express my opinion soo:
For the job of Keeli at first I think the most rational decision is a HC of the server to be put in charge just to kick start the COMPANY and afterwards with a watchful eye, the people who progress in KC may get evaluated for the position of Keeli and its progression, I am not saying anything should be rushed, everything in it's time I belive. 
Also I really thought about the idea that it is a company why not make a full stop at the rank of Keeli, that is Captain and make Captain in KC be even to a BCMD in a battalion, I thought of that, because I always envisioned KC as a small type company, with dedicated people, around 6-7 max I believe and make them a quick response squad/unit. 
Also  KC may have had one episode but out of all the CW episodes, this was one will be always my favourite, as it showed great many things that I really look up to. 
Have fun everyone

I know its ambigious but it's an idea only

Edited January 15, 2021 by Cutlaw

[Heart]

4 minutes ago, Cutlaw said:

Well, I want to express my opinion soo:
For the job of Keeli at first I think the most rational decision is a HC of the server to be put in charge just to kick start the COMPANY and afterwards with a watchful eye, the people who progress in KC may get evaluated for the position of Keeli and its progression, I am not saying anything should be rushed, everything in it's time I belive. 
Also I really thought about the idea that it is a company why not make a full stop at the rank of Keeli, that is Captain and make Captain in KC be even to a BCMD in a battalion, I thought of that, because I always envisioned KC as a small type company, with dedicated people, around 6-7 max I believe and make them a quick response squad/unit. 
Also  KC may have had one episode but out of all the CW episodes, this was one will be always my favourite, as it showed great many things that I really look up to. 
Have fun everyone

I know its ambigious but it's an idea only

So, SOBDE without being SOBDE

[Cutlaw]

Just now, Heart said:

So, SOBDE without being SOBDE

It... kind of sounds like that, maybe something like middle ground between SOBDE and the normal battalions

[Marvel]

This has to be a joke....

-1

This is one of the most vague suggestions ever for something as huge as adding an entire battalion onto the server.

[KillJoy]

YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES. Also talk with Jedi to get the Lore Master with the Boys. +1 Dumb me I don't care. Keeli is a badass

[Jack]

-1 not needed currently, we already have issues with our current battalions no need to add more

[Fyi]

-1 I'm sorry, I really would love to see new battalions come into the server, but we really can't handle more than we currently have. We need to fix the issues within the current battalions and hopefully in the future we'll get some more members to open the door for more battalions and groups.

[Maddoxx]

-1 

As fun as getting new battalion is, we have battalions struggling for numbers as is. Adding a new battalion just wouldn’t work with the server in its current state. 

[Logic]

-1 

if it was 91st sure, but not this budget neyo crap. 

[Brooklyn]

All of Keeli Company died in Phase 1. Early in the clone wars. Wouldn’t make sense -1

[Cutlaw]

[Forseen]

2 hours ago, Brooklyn said:

All of Keeli Company died in Phase 1. Early in the clone wars. Wouldn’t make sense -1

Bit of a silly argument considering a few different groups on the server :P

[Ket]

We asked for these when the 91st was around as another sub branch, what's the point of adding them now?

-1

[Stockings]

-1 Unnecessary if we had to completely restructure a battalion the other day. Other battalions would be more suitable as well.

[Guac]

Ya know what, I may of +1'd if you had made more of a convincing argument.

With that being said, I ain't convinced. We should take into consideration that a battalion recently was fucking

n u k e d

because of failing leadership. Kinda redundant to thin our forces even more. Lets work with what we have :)!

-1 for now.

Edited January 15, 2021 by Guac

[Willyworm1]

-1 It's not that it's inherently bad, it's just that the reason 187th, 327th, and 91st was removed is the same reason we aren't making new battalions. And in my opinion, if anything, 327th should be re added instead (but i'm biased in that regard).

[Slak]

Ganna have to -1 this. 

[Hanz]

-1 I think this is the wrong time to suggest this. If 21st ends up failing and is removed, I think you have a chance to suggest this again, but rn. I agreed with @Bleachfor once

[Craigary]

+1 POG.

I know this wont get added though.

In a perfect world if we had the ability to have all the battalions while maintaining good numbers with everyone, I think the community would appreciate having keelys company. However its sad we cant but understandable as to why we cant.

[Brooklyn]

14 hours ago, Forseen said:

Bit of a silly argument considering a few different groups on the server :P

fair. But the battalion in its entirety was killed. Like literally no remnants left. Unlike the current battalions on the server 

[Gaster]

-1, I've seen every battalion that gets added die. There hype around it for about a month then no one cares. Some battalion aren't doing so good now so adding a completely new one would just hurt the server more than help it. Maybe we could add a battalion once the current ones are stable were getting numbers like we used to. But as of now adding it wouldn't help anyone.

[Scribbles]

Cool as this is, -1.

As much as i want Imma Gunna Die

[Shake]

-1 

 

[Maverick]

Died in Phase 1 you say? as Forseen said...theres a few different groups that are dead but still here...

 

-1 Don't need more battalions. Fix current ones.

[40Ninjaman]

-1 my dude. I love you vertical, but even i know the battalions on the server need work themselves. The recent 21st wipe speaks a lot for itself.

[Aeon]

-1 

[Egg]

-1 for reasons previously stated. 

[Mitchell]

-1.

[Pog]

-1 for the extensive list of reasons previously stated. 

[Pxnda]

-1, Do you wanna see 91st die off once more? 

[justuscloud5]

On 1/14/2021 at 10:42 PM, Dinaric said:

-1 187th, 327th, and 91st, have either been removed for huge inactivity, or lack of leadership.

 

-1

[CruorFlumine]

-1, nah, its pretty pointless right now. We dont need more battalions and we need to work on the leadership of the current ones before considering adding another

[Comics]

-1, no need for more battalions that will crash and burn

[Rezz]

-1. Why add another battalion that will just be empty. If we had battalions like 327th and 91st back and they were thriving then i would 100% like to see this be added regardless of them being wiped out before phase two was even in circulation,  but with the lack of new players we get its just not possible to add another battalion.

Edited January 16, 2021 by Rezz

[Dennis]

-1 this ain’t it chief 

1. These are IFN models, so not a great start 

2. The current state of the server doesn’t allow another squad or battalion to be added 

3. They offer nothing special or unique they are a copy paste of the 501st and 212th

Edited January 16, 2021 by Dennis
spelling cuz im dent

[J.Jefferson]

2 minutes ago, Dennis said:

-1 this ain’t it chief 

1. These are IFN models, do not a great start 

2. The current state of the server doesn’t allow another squad or battalion to be added 

3. They offer nothing special or unique they are a copy paste of the 501st and 212th

Just gonna debunk this. First, every battalion on the server is the same because everyone can do training for what x battalion does making that battalion unless. 2nd off we use IFN models on the server so I don’t know what kind of argument that is. 

 

- 1 

[Forseen]

1 hour ago, J.Jefferson said:

we use IFN models on the server

We actually don't use IFN models... We have our own [SR] Model base which was specifically made for us.

[Wren]

-1 


ALSO JUST BECAUSE THEY DIED IN PHASE 1 DOESNT MEAN THEY SHOULD BE ADDED. Most clones on SR are dead lore wise lol

[Otter]

-1 

we don’t need a new battalion but they should put the model on the event clone trooper job

[Pythin]

Fix the current issues, then think about making new battalions. 
-1

[Zensras]

-1

How about we put a ban on asking for new battalions until pop gets a little better and current issues are worked out?

[Clank]

-1. Until we fix our massive issues already present in the current battalions, adding another one is NOT the way to go. I thought after watching 91st, 327th,  and 187th get removed you'd all understand that finally. Guess not.

[Moose]

-1 lol they dead af

[traditional]

Unfortunately, this suggestion has been DENIED.
If the same suggestion is submitted again within 60 DAYS of this post it will be automatically denied.

// LOCKED
// MOVED TO [CW] SERVER SUGGESTIONS - DENIED
 

Quote

Denial reasons:
(These are some reasons that your suggestion might get denied for.)

• Not providing sufficient information.
  Ex: Just linking the workshop and not giving us the actual model path you want to use.
• The addon's size is way too big compared to its content(s).
  Ex: 35MB for one model.
• Majority negative feedback.
• Bad optimization and/or causes bad performance on the server.
• Having multiple suggestions within one thread.
• Bothering leadership/development team regarding a suggestion.
• Suggesting a previously denied suggestion within 60 days of denial.