Whether you wanted to steal or not you fucking did it.
This is not one of those situations where you can say "it was only a small thing", they copy pasted a whole fucking document and knew they were doing it. there are no excuses. His second chance was when he was banned.
And it was far far more than you little discord. Many people were messaged who had no connection to Sugga; same goes for Valor.
Why didn't he ask for appeal earlier, why have they only come crawling back after their community perished. If they wanted to stay in synergy maybe they shouldn't have stolen Synergy's content.
So no Sugga doesn't deserve a 3rd chance. he doesn't even seem sorry, so don't even try to defend him.
If I were you I wouldn't even try to defend these fucking leeches.
Also Sugga was given Kelso's battalion, which was in a great state already, so his Rex term doesn't prove anything.