Dyn

Bug Type (Server:): Broken Hurtboxes Severity level (1-3): 1? Evidence (if you can): Myself, Pepsi, and Jester witnessed it. We didn't record it at the time though. Description of the bug: Non-CGI jedi models cannot hit anything with their lightsabers. The saber does not make contact with other people or with objects in the environment. How can we recreate it: Hop on a non-CGI body grouper for Jedi and attempt to hit a different target (we only tested on players, may be the same for droids).

+1 Personally, I've only had to work with you on a few matters but both times you were very calm and helpful while handling them. You seem like one of the more well adjusted members of the server honestly and I think that your experience as well as your interactions says a lot for yourself in itself. I do agree that perhaps your application could be a bit more filled out, but I still think you've shown yourself to be the best applicant for the position thus far.

I dunno, I think Cody might have a shot. But he didn't rip apart B2s/mandos in hand to hand combat.

+1 I dig this one a lot.

LOA over.

Family friend passed away in ICU. Going to be gone a few days. Steam ID: ‎STEAM_0:0:33476423 RP Name: Castle / Bacara Battalion: 21stNC Who is in command until you return?: Paladin, Bane, Gadget Length of Absence: 9/20/21 - 9/25/21

Wait, RPS? I thought they were going to receive the PLX

6/10 I enjoyed what you tried to do, but there wasn't much substance after the initial glance.

+1 I think you did a really good work during your time as Yularen, are generally pleasant to try to work with, and are probably exactly what CG needs right now in terms of a guiding hand.

6/10 That explosion at the end crashed my game but other than that it kept us busy I suppose.

6/10 Kept us pretty entertained, I had no idea what was going on storywise though.

The issue stated was that BH go to somewhere they might not want to be (instead of Village) while clones end up exactly where they're required to go. Not sure what comparison you're bringing? If the issue is NLR, that could just be brought up to Guild Lead on the matter of people returning.

+1 Maxwells says it isn't much trouble to implement so that's about my only concern gone. I think it could be cool and it would take out the trouble mediaplayer cutscenes where they have to record everything prior and all.

To be honest, I kinda agree with Maxwells. Rules are only effective when the ability exists to properly enforce them (which means you'd have to prove someone is doing it in the first place). If you're a hostile BH returning to Anaxes, why not just walk up to the TP and swap jobs to achieve the same effect? Nobody will care and it'll keep you out of the base.

+1 Same place as others, if the council wants to switch out a master for a master then it's cool with me. I'd like to see more lore padawans/knights though personally.

Damn, lost a real one right here

8/10 Was a pretty solid deployment, good story and good action.

As long as you believe that you can keep your mental health in a good place while handling all the responsibilities, I'm willing to +1 this app. Though I would encourage you to take LOAs as necessary. It's a struggle and it isn't easy to just make these things go away.

Alright. I'm going to give my own opinion as well as offer some context where I can (if I can) to some of the matters that have been brought up throughout the thread. So since the beginning of his term, Deku has been steadily trying to push for things to help communication. He wanted us to do CMD meetings despite everyone bellyaching because it gave us all an avenue to express issues with our own/other battalions and allowed battalion leaders to actually communicate beyond just the memes in discord regarding server things. Before these, the discord basically only got notifications about troublemakers while after we brought up actual big changes (which I won't disclose as I'm not sure if the ones who proposed them would want me to). This is also true. When I had myself placed under unnecessary stress because of matters that were out of my hands, I was able to reach out on the topics to only a handful of people really. Those being Bro and Deku who took the time and effort to help dig me out of the situation and allow me to feel like I had control of things again. Not to throw blame on others, but doesn't this reflect more on part of the BCMDs and the REGs above them then? I'm willing to own up that I've still yet to accomplish all I want in 21st since Agent's resignation and I think we still need to build up solid numbers as well. I don't necessarily want to comment on the other bats but I'm curious what is considered lackluster? Numbers? General battalion attitude? I do think the points you brought up about Odric are a lot more grounded though and were worth addressing. Overall though, I'm going to give my +1 on the topic. Deku has personally helped me quite a bit and I appreciate it as it has allowed me to refocus my efforts on the 21st again and start implementing healthy changes once more.

I'm personally fine with either candidates and I enjoy talking to you from time to time when matters come up. I don't really care about your prior history either as I think most people can shake that with effort and work. Though what I am concerned about is what Ratio mentioned above. I consider mental health an extremely important subject and from the sounds of it, it is being stated you're not in the best place to tackle this task. Obviously, I don't know you as well as Ratio might though so I'd like to hear from you first before I make any actual decision either way on the topic (whether DM or here).

+1 You're literally the worst Bird and I hate you. I'm not answering this for him per say but offering my insight to this as someone who does something similar. The application can be used to express interest in the unit and give time for the people organizing the unit and officers to watch the conduct of the trooper in question as well as review prior history. The tryout itself could be a skills/knowledge check afterwards. An application takes like 15 mins at most tbh so I don't really see it as much an issue.

The issue is that if you bring up all the features without specifying which ones you want implemented, it will be assumed all the ones you listed were being pushed for. Overall though, my opinion stays about the same. Most of these are ultimately unnecessary or even harmful to balance imo while providing little if any benefits.

-1 I could see potential trouble involving some of the things you listed as features for opposing forces. In addition to the concerns I listed below though, I'm just a bit worried about how intensive these features might be on the server itself. Ultimately, I don't think it promotes roleplay itself more than what we have and comes with more flaws than positives. Not sure the reason why founders denied it but I assume my opinion won't change regardless. If there was an x-ray or shared camera, it could grant information of an enemy's location without them saying a word (if either they die or they're shooting and people in the squad notice despite being a bit away). This would only make things like droids attempting to sneak into base for events or BHs accomplishing anti-republic bounties harder. I'm not sure what weapons you'd be sending to your team since we can't buy them except from the vendor and you can already give money to allies. Minimap is kinda weird and falls into the whole just communicate issue from before. Seeing squad health is the same suggestion we just had so use ACE or just inform medics when low. Multiple voice channels or a text chat only squad have to read for orders might be nice though.

3/10 The event started off strong with storming the beach, but something I didn't get was making a vote for if an event should be 1 life or not. I figure that's something you should figure out before it happened. Also asking people to stay around for however long the duration might be (we don't know, it could be anywhere from 30 mins to 3 hours) is kinda a bit much. The BX droid with the great treeline, a sniper, and height advantage was pretty harsh when we're also working with no med revives.

-1 Don't let a sudden event interrupt scheduled trainings (or bring an abrupt halt to an ongoing tryout before people have a chance to mark things down and pick it up later).