Just a quick disclaimer, I was not involved at all with the 5th grader drama that involved Logic, but I instead witnessed the events unfold as a bystander.
Ok my guy here we go. Ima be real, what you did back then was just not cool, in any sense of the word. It frankly left a sour taste of the server in my mouth and was one of main reasons as to why I decided to take a break from this community again. I'm not one for getting hung up on past events, especially on a Garry's mod server, and I also firmly believe people change with time. However, the drama you caused and the nuisance it was for everyone involved or witnessing it was literally enough to get myself and a hand full of other people to leave for a while. I've legitimately never seen such a clown fiesta in any other video game or community and that's saying something. This is ultimately why I'm giving you a -1. All you were was a pain in the ass and a gnarly stain on this servers history. Out of a childish fit of rage you made life hell for many people in this community, many people who were and still are genuinely great fellas. The reaction you got out of them was to be expected and in my eyes only natural, though not excusable. In my opinion you should not be allowed back due to the personality and priorities that you showed you had, as you behaved more like an ape with a keyboard and mic than a Human being with "Logic".
With that out of the way. I wish you good luck with the appeal, and should you be allowed back, I genuinely hope that you really did change for the better.