Okay here's the thing. Yes I may have not been there, however when a staff member asks you to leave an area or stop spamming in OOC, he has the right to mute. Yes, I will get you about using the phy gun, since the only time that should be used on a player is if they are afk infront of a door. I do also understand that Smalljeff is considered high command when he is on Shakk ti, but he wasn't on that character. He was on his clone! In this case, Carvis has the right to give a warning, which he did, and then acted on it when they didn't stop. So stop thinking since Smalljeff is Shakk ti, he's immune to server rules when hes on his clone.
Final Verdict -1 to the staff report, yes rookie move to use the phy gun, but you did what was right in my eyes.