Glory22

That addon is bad and hardly works. Current shield is better and just needs some development to help improve it when you’re moving with it.

+1 easy change that would be beneficial.

Hm, I do think that some good points are made here from all sides. I would think that a better thing would be to utilize your shields more often. Also, the DP24 is not going to do much against the shotgun or some of the other weaponry available to people willing to fork out the money for it. As someone primarily guarded by SG and DS, I do think some improvement could be made, however most of the time I see attacks from Separatists / NPCs affecting us rather than by BHs. I've heard and seen that the hitbox on your shield is very bad when it is being held by DS until it is placed. Perhaps a better avenue would be to improve the protection offered by the shield when it is being held or when people are moving around with it, which would make the shield something used much more often and taken advantage of both for you guys and if/when DU comes back (until that time, the shield is something totally unique to DS and is a cool draw that I feel is underused). It's shown in the clone wars to be extremely good when being held and offering near total protection to those using it, and I see it being used well during trainings, but I very rarely see it used in events or during normal times due to these lackings. Not going to vote as either way would be a benefit to some extent for you guys, but that is my take on the matter: Rather than add this weapon (which is by most accounts, mine included, a downgrade to the DC15A/S) improve the shield's hitbox and protection which would enable much more RP and tactical combat!

+1

I do not believe that utility items such as this should be made a permanent weapon, let alone for that much. That would just take something that’s meant to add RP for a battalion, subunit, or specialization that any newer player could acquire and have fun with and lock it behind a paywall that most people would never get close to reaching. There’s already enough on the server for 99% of the “whales” to purchase.

Would theoretically be possible if it was made a server rule and staff were told only to bring people for revive if a med made a ticket but I do think that limiting that isn’t the way to go. 100% I think this would help the server and add more RP (such as being able to find someone’s corpse then revive it). If you made a suggestion for this I would +1 it.

+1 Capable of being a very good Wolffe!

Gameplay: 5/5 - Fun for Senators as you played along with the RP we were doing Care and Effort: 5/5 - Cool dupe and good staff responsiveness Server Performance: 4/5 - Some FPS issues

Bug Type (Server:): Spawns (CWRP) Severity level (Low - Medium - High): Low Evidence (if you can): Myself and other Senators have noticed it quite often in the past few weeks. Description of the bug: Randomly spawning in the Navy bunks rather than Senate bunks or Mas Amedda's office. Has been happening since switch to Helix. How can we recreate it: Use a Senator job for a while and you'll notice it.

-1 Change the boarding rules so that you can be carried up in a LAAT rather than try to grapple from ground level up to a ship up in the sky. Not only are you hurting your own battalion with that rule but you’re hurting SUP server-wide with that. Something like this would be way better suited for ARF server-wide (if there was no performance issues) so they can climb the rocks on the map rather than getting added just for your subunit.

In that case if those glass areas would not cut it, then I am not terribly sure on what else could be done as I am not really a mapper nor staff so I can't really get good up-to-date images of the map to really inspect in that sense. Are there some things currently on the map that are brushes that could be converted into props? For the citadel, I think the barricades and towers could be made into props if they were not already, which would probably lower the number of brushes needed by a lot. If the Community has any feedback on areas that could be shrunk or simplified in terms of geometry that could be helpful as well!

Well I am unsure how much is needed to be removed, but I think that some of the decorative areas that are only visible through glass (such as below the bunks area) could be removed. The second sector could be downsized a bit, with some of the areas being made to be more open by removing trees and rocks. Remove some trees on the main layer of the map as well. Also, I believe there are two dueling arenas (not sure), but if so one could be removed since I doubt there'd often be two going on at a time. I could think of others but I'm unsure how many brushes are really needed and how many this would get back. If more is needed, please let me know so I can put some more thought into it.

Gameplay: 5/5 - Good downed ship RP Care and Effort: 5/5 - Very engaging and fun idea Server Performance: 5/5 - No issues

-1 for the same reasons this was denied: It also is way faster than 1hp/sec.

Name: Keegan RP Rank: Vice Chair Mas Amedda Suggestion: Add the Citadel Challenge SIM room to the map. Implementation: Rip the old citadel from the Synergy Venator (it is better than the Anaxes one, and if we ever start using that Venator again the dupes can be reused between maps) and fit it in an empty area of the map and put a teleporter to it. Otherwise, if it fits, try to place it next to the other sim rooms in one of these two locations: Add door in the green room and have the entrance there. Add a door here with a hall going back and to the left with the Citadel there. Lore: Citadel Challenge | Wookieepedia | Fandom Workshop content if applicable: Require Development (If no workshop content, suggest a developer or put "Require Development")

+1 definitely capable of staff imo and has a good drive for it.

Do you think crafting should come to the sever? Yes would be fun what type of crafting would you like to see? (ie. Stims, meds, drugs, guns etc) Stims, meds, drugs, guns, jetpacks, barricades, etc. how in-depth should this system be? (Very basic 1+1=2 or sub components to craft main components to make one big thing) Subcomponents would be nice

So, I was waiting for this one. You did a lot of damage on the server, and did hurt my reputation a lot. When you alted into the Senate as Henry Dick, I was one of the people present at the selection, and then you become 41st HVO twice under me, both times blowing up a debrief. While this was really upsetting to me in terms of breaching my trust, and I heard that High Staff was investigating me for this, in the end I've come to kind of accept it and realize that the things you did to me are things that I can get over and live with. Before you blew up debrief, you were extremely productive as a member of the Senate and 41st. I had literally promoted you seconds before the incident. After your alting in December as you mentioned, you reached out to me a bit after regarding how you wanted to appeal and come back to the server. This was somewhat surprising to me, as I had figured you would just keep alting until HVO was eventually disbanded in its entirety due to repeated issues. After a lot of discussion, as well as playing some Battlefront across a few days with you to help facilitate it and reminisce on old times from when we were in 501st back in early 2022, I've heard your side of this situation and kinda understand why you did some of these things, and kept coming back. You've explained these things in your post, so I won't go too much in detail on them, but honestly the only real issues I see with allowing you back right now are the things you sent in Discord. As people mentioned already, slurs and inappropriate messages can really hurt people. However, at this point that damage is done. Making an appeal like this would be useless to you if you intended to keep doing that, as you could've just kept alting in game and Discord if you wanted to do so. Making an appeal would be a waste of time if you didn't intend to discontinue these actions (which you have as far as I can tell), and as such I think you are genuine here. All the screenshots and stuff I see is things from before his last alting, which is when he is saying he stopped everything. I'm going to +1 this as I know you are young, and although you were influenced by people around you, you accept your actions as your own and have reached out to dozens of people on the server to apologize and make this right, even trying to do so when you saw people from here on other communities. I think you deserve a chance here on the server, and would likely receive a similar watchlist status as other people who have returned, which would really limit the extent of damage that could be done (if you did do something, which as I said I don't believe you will).

Can't believe this

So, would this still be a claimable zone by staff or battalions for events or trainings? I imagine there's going to be a lot of problems with RDM or breaking BH rules when it comes to where the line is drawn with this (where the area around Thesh ends), and people not reading adverts since there is no claim board there to claim it that way. This map is already so limited in the structured areas that we can really do events or trainings in that don't require a massive dupe, and this would hinder that substantially. Onderon is beautiful but very difficult to use as a basic NCO or Admin who can't really do too much on their own in terms of setting things up. The entire Jedi planet / sector 2 is not even comparable to the possibilities that Endor, Geonosis, and Umbara offered when we were on Anaxes. Cut the thing out and add those back in and I'd be more willing to do sacrifice this tiny building that is one of the few places that events and trainings happen at on this map. I'd rather sacrifice a portion of sector 2 to this as then we aren't losing as much opportunity in that sense.

Very impressive and well deserved! Congratulations, Rancor!

+1 makes sense to have Warthog included in getting a jetpack

Gameplay: 4/5 - Fun but annoying to get blown up by trandos who shoot directly at their feet and survive since they're HPed high Care and Effort: 5/5 - Engaging dupe spanning a lot of the map Server Performance: 5/5 - No isses

+1 Pleasant to speak to and mature. Definitely capable of staff and has a good motivation to go for staff.

Bug Type (Server:): Main - Quests Severity level (Low - Medium - High): Low Evidence (if you can): (Also reported to be an issue on Lux Bonteri job) Description of the bug: People on Senate jobs can do the BH quests which they should not be able to do. How can we recreate it: Switch to a Senator job and go to the BH quest person.