Mystic Posted February 10, 2024 Developer Posted February 10, 2024 (edited) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Name: Mystic Suggestion: Remove the rep reduction associated with the "Disagree" react. Why should we implement this? If confused doesn't take away rep i don't see why disagree should. Dumb is already used in place of it, Agree is generally a positive thing as well as "Friendly" and "Pay Respects" but with "Disagree" basically being the equivalent to "i disagree with your opinion or your statement" it seems dumb that it removes reputation. Since its essentially a nicer way of dumbing someone and most people just use the dumb react anyways. Dumb should stay the only negative reaction as it is the only one directly associated with negativity. To be completely honest, I'd rather see Agree/Disagree lose their +Rep and -Rep together than keep disagree as a -rep. Both should be used to show you agree or disagree. Neither should particularly affect reputation since neither is postive/negative How will this improve the Forums? It really wont change a whole lot, it's impact would likely be the same as when they changed "Pay Respects" to give positive reputation. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Edited February 11, 2024 by Mystic 5 2 1 1 Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Nothing l Senior Developer Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu l Final SO Blackout l Grand Master Yoda l CG DSO Thorn
Developer Posted February 10, 2024 (edited) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Name: Mystic Suggestion: Remove the rep reduction associated with the "Disagree" react. Why should we implement this? If confused doesn't take away rep i don't see why disagree should. Dumb is already used in place of it, Agree is generally a positive thing as well as "Friendly" and "Pay Respects" but with "Disagree" basically being the equivalent to "i disagree with your opinion or your statement" it seems dumb that it removes reputation. Since its essentially a nicer way of dumbing someone and most people just use the dumb react anyways. Dumb should stay the only negative reaction as it is the only one directly associated with negativity. To be completely honest, I'd rather see Agree/Disagree lose their +Rep and -Rep together than keep disagree as a -rep. Both should be used to show you agree or disagree. Neither should particularly affect reputation since neither is postive/negative How will this improve the Forums? It really wont change a whole lot, it's impact would likely be the same as when they changed "Pay Respects" to give positive reputation. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Edited February 11, 2024 by Mystic 5 2 1 1 Longest Special Operations Member on the server. Current: Nothing l Senior Developer Former: Cin Drallig l First Yayax Squad Yover l Foxtrot Commando l 2nd GM BCMD Bacara l Serra Keto l Final SO Commander Jet l First & Last Devil Dogs Deadeye l Veteran Admin l Jedi General Plo Koon l 2nd Returning SO CMD Jet l Luminara Unduli l Wolfpack MAJ Boost l Kit Fisto l Trauma's Unit MED Mystic l Jedi Military Advisor l Omega 36 PVT Darman l High General Shaak Ti l Jedi Chief Instructor l Alpha 98 Nate l Actually Private Crosshair l Mace Windu l Final SO Blackout l Grand Master Yoda l CG DSO Thorn
GregWasTaken Posted February 10, 2024 Posted February 10, 2024 (edited) +1 I sort of have an internal debate, on one side if agree gives +rep, disagree should give -rep. To me it is obvious that agree should give +rep. On the other hand, you can disagree with someone without it being a bad thing. I disagree with plenty of people, but I don't mean it negatively. Overall I think this is a good idea. People agreeing with you should give +rep, and disagreeing should not conversely give you -rep. I do believe, however, that dumb should not be the only reaction that gives -rep. It feels too limited. I believe that "Bruh" and maybe a new reaction such as like... A thumbs down emoji that just means "Bad post" should be added. Not every bad post is dumb, and not every dumb post is a bad post. Bruh is also represented by a skull, and is pretty much never used positively. Edited February 10, 2024 by GregWasTaken 1 1 Hey there! I'm Greg!
Posted February 10, 2024 (edited) +1 I sort of have an internal debate, on one side if agree gives +rep, disagree should give -rep. To me it is obvious that agree should give +rep. On the other hand, you can disagree with someone without it being a bad thing. I disagree with plenty of people, but I don't mean it negatively. Overall I think this is a good idea. People agreeing with you should give +rep, and disagreeing should not conversely give you -rep. I do believe, however, that dumb should not be the only reaction that gives -rep. It feels too limited. I believe that "Bruh" and maybe a new reaction such as like... A thumbs down emoji that just means "Bad post" should be added. Not every bad post is dumb, and not every dumb post is a bad post. Bruh is also represented by a skull, and is pretty much never used positively. Edited February 10, 2024 by GregWasTaken 1 1 Hey there! I'm Greg!
Finn Posted February 10, 2024 Posted February 10, 2024 If Agree gives 1 rep, Disagree should remove 1 rep. They're opposites. -1 3 3 Command Team Union Representative | Longest Serving Attack Regimental Commander Master of Quests | 212th Shadow BCMD | Retired
Posted February 10, 2024 If Agree gives 1 rep, Disagree should remove 1 rep. They're opposites. -1 3 3 Command Team Union Representative | Longest Serving Attack Regimental Commander Master of Quests | 212th Shadow BCMD | Retired
Kortnul Posted February 12, 2024 Posted February 12, 2024 +1 I don't disagree with this. 1 Current: Dumbass Former: 501st ARFL LTC Boomer, 104th WP HVYL COL Sinker, Doom's Unit MEDL CPT Kortnul, 212th Ghost Company ARCL CPT Reed, Omega 15 CPT Fi x2, Omega 22 SGM Atin , Omega 09 CPT Niner , Veteran Admin x2, Alpha-74 SGT Stec
Posted February 12, 2024 +1 I don't disagree with this. 1 Current: Dumbass Former: 501st ARFL LTC Boomer, 104th WP HVYL COL Sinker, Doom's Unit MEDL CPT Kortnul, 212th Ghost Company ARCL CPT Reed, Omega 15 CPT Fi x2, Omega 22 SGM Atin , Omega 09 CPT Niner , Veteran Admin x2, Alpha-74 SGT Stec
Joyboy Posted February 14, 2024 Posted February 14, 2024 +1 You can disagree and it not be a negative thing, plus like was previously stated Dumb is basically the one people use to negatively impact rep. 1 1 Current: My Chains are Broken Former: Jedi General Anakin Skywalker, 501st BCMD Rex, ATK RCMD Joyboy, Jedi Knight Etain Tur-Mukan, Jedi Master Arligan Zey, CG CPT Stone, Bad Batch Tech, Rakata Guild Leader, Omega Squad XO Darman, Omega Squad Lead Niner, Jedi Branch Overseer Luminara Unduli, Jedi Master of the Order Mace Windu, Jedi Grand Master of the Order Yoda x2, Null 5 LT Prudii, Naval RID Captain Armand Isard, DS CPT Stone
Posted February 14, 2024 +1 You can disagree and it not be a negative thing, plus like was previously stated Dumb is basically the one people use to negatively impact rep. 1 1 Current: My Chains are Broken Former: Jedi General Anakin Skywalker, 501st BCMD Rex, ATK RCMD Joyboy, Jedi Knight Etain Tur-Mukan, Jedi Master Arligan Zey, CG CPT Stone, Bad Batch Tech, Rakata Guild Leader, Omega Squad XO Darman, Omega Squad Lead Niner, Jedi Branch Overseer Luminara Unduli, Jedi Master of the Order Mace Windu, Jedi Grand Master of the Order Yoda x2, Null 5 LT Prudii, Naval RID Captain Armand Isard, DS CPT Stone
Hanz Posted February 14, 2024 Posted February 14, 2024 All the people with bad opinions deserve to have low rep -1 2 1 3
Edgar Posted February 14, 2024 Posted February 14, 2024 I stand against Bacta +1 1 1 2 1 I've been around the server for a couple of years. The Original CT PVT AdminAbuser™
Posted February 14, 2024 I stand against Bacta +1 1 1 2 1 I've been around the server for a couple of years. The Original CT PVT AdminAbuser™
Guac Posted February 15, 2024 Forum Admin Posted February 15, 2024 As it stands, the reputation function is intended to be a physical representation of the communities perception of you. Because of this, if you are giving opinions that are generally disagreed with, that your reputation is impacted, and vice-versa. If you'd like to disagree with an opinion and not directly effect someones reputation, it makes sense that instead you use a reply or comment to voice that disagreement. 1 2 2 🎀 𝙵𝚊𝚛𝚝 𝚂𝚖𝚎𝚕𝚕𝚊 🎀 <3
Forum Admin Posted February 15, 2024 As it stands, the reputation function is intended to be a physical representation of the communities perception of you. Because of this, if you are giving opinions that are generally disagreed with, that your reputation is impacted, and vice-versa. If you'd like to disagree with an opinion and not directly effect someones reputation, it makes sense that instead you use a reply or comment to voice that disagreement. 1 2 2 🎀 𝙵𝚊𝚛𝚝 𝚂𝚖𝚎𝚕𝚕𝚊 🎀 <3
Guac Posted February 15, 2024 Forum Admin Posted February 15, 2024 Unfortunately this suggestion has been DENIED. For more information on why this suggestion was denied, please contact a Forum Admin+ // LOCKED // MOVED TO FORUM SUGGESTIONS - DENIED 1 🎀 𝙵𝚊𝚛𝚝 𝚂𝚖𝚎𝚕𝚕𝚊 🎀 <3
Forum Admin Posted February 15, 2024 Unfortunately this suggestion has been DENIED. For more information on why this suggestion was denied, please contact a Forum Admin+ // LOCKED // MOVED TO FORUM SUGGESTIONS - DENIED 1 🎀 𝙵𝚊𝚛𝚝 𝚂𝚖𝚎𝚕𝚕𝚊 🎀 <3
Recommended Posts