TLDR: -1 is my personal, but i could +1 I would be fine with this but you have the wrong reasons.
1) The stagnation is irrelevant because you have the cabinet in place. They are there not only to enforce rules and assist the Leader, but to give him ideas and help him with changes, and new rules. Their entire existence is so they can assist and support the leader. Also would you say eggs multiple terms as Gree caused a stagnation in the Battalion? If so then he should no longer continue being Gree. (love you Egg) The role of the Clan Leaders is to ensure that stagnation doesn’t exist, if they see something they don’t like they are allowed to remove the current leader.
2) I kind of agree here, while just being appointed to a position just forces the underlings of the bounty hunters to just bend to their will. They don’t have a say in the matter. The voting on the applications will let them have a say as well. The power playing in BH is supposed to be apparent, and as a Guild Leader you need to be careful and play around it. It’s a fun dance between impeachment and staying the favorite.
3) I agree The guild leader should be present at the commander meetings, I’m in the HC discord and I encourage people to give me names and reports of people who break the rules/minge and I have swift and hard justice upon them.
The bounty hunter system is that of checks and balances, if any of this confused you please ask me to specify and i will.