Leaderboard

AIght so saying that jedi generals were not high command makes absolutely no sense. They ran battalions and ran most things in the republic they were the high command of the clones and saying Like when joah ran the 501st he wasn't in charge when anakin was around thats how it should be but as well its up to bcmd giving the power. The reason we mad it like this is because for one JEDI POWER GOES WITH WHAT THE BCMDS GIVE YOU IF YOU READ THE JEDI RULES YOU WOULD KNOW. SECONDLY TO EVEN GET THE RANK OF JEDI GENERAL YOU HAVE TO BE A MASTER+ WHICH IS HARD AS FUCK TO GET AND AS WELL IN ITSELF EVEN HARDER TO GET TO GENERAL CAUSE OF THE RANKING. THIRDLY I WANNA SAY THIS AGAIN BCMDS GIVE THE RIGHTS TO THE JEDI IN THE BATTALION AND AS WELL ANOTHER REASON WE GAVE THEM RCMD IS SO THEY COULD AS WELL BAIL THERE BCMD. AND AS WELL ANYTHING TO DO WITH JEDI HAS GO THROUGH COUNCIL AND YODA AND FORGOT ONE THING THERE HAVE BEEN MULTIPLE CASES THAT WE HAVE DENIED SOMEONE A CHARACTER AND IT HAS BEEN LEFT OPEN FOR A MONTH BEFORE THEY COULD GET IT THERE IS NO FAVORITISM IN THE COUNCIL WHEN I LEFT IT WE PUT PEOPLE IN PLACES WHERE THEY EARNED IT. +1 REVERT THIS CHANGE

I agree with that, everything makes more sens lore wise, but look at the server, its serious RP but not really, people Dont RP what so ever as clone, they RP like themself within star wars. This is what I hate. And I support 100% making it more lore accurate, but then Jedi general should be with a application on forums and interview, so it stops favoritism, to an extent. I am also in favor in removing High command, as a previous High command member, I think HC is mostly useless and has no reason, its not even fun to RP as HC and they have a really hard time to Fill it.

They do it to clone all the time, clone has no vote what so ever on rules on them. Jedi gets to vote on almost everything, its not that bad, get over it. Also, we all know if they tried to bring this up to council it would have failed, who would +1 something that demotes them.. its just commun sens, somethings cannot be bring to council, its called conflict of interest.And im pretty sure it is director job to do this, its part of their job to manage the rules. Also have you even take a look at my suggestion ?

Someone’s done pissed the Jedi off. That’s never a good sign +1 revert the change

Clearly not if you got it Anyway yeah +1 make Jedi great again

I'm just generally curious where the favoritism argument is coming from in regards to the High Council, because if it were true I'd go as far as push for a Council wipe if I were a player.

I think I made 3 of them lol

+1 they may be pistols, but in lore several characters use them as primary armaments and it definitely seemed to work.

+1

Ok. Just because you had a grudge against him doesn't mean anything. He wasn't bad in the 41st.

Gonna put it this way, Jedi Generals are not GAR High Command. Sorry not sorry. -1

Let me start this by asking the question, why should the jedi high command matter in terms of equivalence to the normal high command. I've seen from the only negative reply so far that the argument against the jedi is that the role in question does not hold the difficulty of aquisition, (applying) and therefore isn't deserving of the high command authority. I'll address this from two points of lore standing and one point of basic server functionality. Lore wise, clones could and never did outrank a master of the order, with the jedi being the defacto leaders on the ground. The only cases of them being equals to jedi were that of jedi commanders, (padawans.) This is unrealistic, but what was in place worked, and the change was unneeded. On top of this, there shouldn't be any high command as is set up in this server. Commanders were commanders, essentially Marshal commanders led battalions, not all clones. If the change should stay, the high command should be removed to reflect the change. Jedi authority > Clone authority. Lore wise that is. Server wise, the equalization of the ranks reflected the idea of cooperation. Jedi held a rank of power to ensure jedi behaved with clones as high command did vice versa. With the change, lines will be crossed somewhere down the line, all because someone pulls rank. It happens to the best of people, and the change made to the hierarchy only enables these incidents. +1

why bring a debate on this in PM, I feel like its important for the people to see this so it can help them make a choice ? its not a toxic argument we are just talking about it.

Its not that hard honestly, also its not because something is hard to obtain that power should come with it, look at RC/Null tryouts, its a really hard tryouts (yes for some its really easy) but for 99% of the server its a hard one, and when passing you dont obtain more power. So the argument that its hard to obtain so it should get lot of power is terrible, find something better.

why are people so triggered about it, it doesnt change anything really... 🤔 It looks like more of a power angry thing then anything else, have you tought about, making your rank as High command like it was before, but you have to be master+ and put an app on the forums for jedi generals ? that would make sens, since we all know most of the jedi order is full of favoritism and to clone to get that much power has to apply for it, so its only fair for jedi to apply to get the same power ? @Avavel

+1 , dont try to fix, what doesn't need to be fixed.

Name: Fizzik Suggestion: Allow Recon Bats to Leave Base 24/7 Implementation: Anyone in Recon can leave. If everyone is too much, make it a much lower rank to grant leave access, such as 2nd LT. If people don't mind, it'd also be nice to spread this rule out to all Battalion ARC and ARF. Lore: It's Recon battalion's jobs to recon, do patrols and what not. Workshop content if applicable:

+1 Alexz is a good kid. @Colon @PunishedDrayyen Chill out dude

+1 It's literally a forum ban. Chill the fuck out @[SR] Sanchez [SA] Also, @Colon @PunishedDrayyen maybe your battalion should have been active the first time around. <3

-1 suggestion was denied before