Jedi Astromech playermodels/Battalion Astromech/Astromech

[Cutlaw]

If you would like a suggestion to be implemented into the server, you MUST follow this template! Any suggestions that do not follow this template will be denied instantly.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Name: 501st Jedi Padawan Ulnar/501st PLT SGT Cutlaw

Suggestion: Adding the astromech droid job and  playermodel for roleplaying purposes

Implementation: Uhm, I do not understand that section, but I think to add them to the add-on pack?

Lore: http://clonewars.wikia.com/wiki/Astromech_Droid

Workshop content if applicable: https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=820347922&searchtext=Astromech
(If no workshop content, suggest a developer or put "Require Development")

If you are asking to add or change a job, fill out the following

Add or Change: Add astromechs as a job

Job: Astromech Droid

Model:  https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=820347922&searchtext=Astromech ( It is the same as the first link ;3 )

Weapons: A jetpack ( optional, but would be grateful if we had one ), a grappling hook ( optional, I don't know that you used to use the hooks, and I joined somewhat after they got removed, so I am just putting them ), and a repair tool

Other: Uhm, nothing more, just wanted to make the jobs more diverse and with roleplay, wouldn't be cool if we had droids running around repairing ships, not just changing names as staff and doing it, it's going to be so fun! I hope you guys will like the idea, it will be a lot of fun!

Have a nice day! Also READ THE REPLIES

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Edited June 19, 2018 by Cutlaw

[Firat/Abi]

4 minutes ago, Cutlaw said:

Implementation: Uhm, I do not understand that section, but I think to add them to the add-on pack?

Yes thats what they meant. 

Besides that +1 

[Cutlaw]

Man, so grateful you actually +1, I would love to see Fleet roleplaying with the droids <3

[Nade Jones]

We do not want the majority of the server running around making beeping noises, although its fun we do have an R2D2 job which is your only bet at beeping around.

-1

[Cutlaw]

Uhm, it won't be the whole ship, it would be around 5-10 max, we won't have the beeping sounds and we could always make a rule about the droids if someone abuses it. Well, it's your choice, but just saying that the roleplay is important, not actually thinking that it would be a constant minge on the ship, because of them..

[Nade Jones]

1 minute ago, Cutlaw said:

Uhm, it won't be the whole ship, it would be around 5-10 max, we won't have the beeping sounds and we could always make a rule about the droids if someone abuses it. Well, it's your choice, but just saying that the roleplay is important, not actually thinking that it would be a constant minge on the ship, because of them..

Its possible it could be controlled to prevent minginess but still, what roleplay capabilities does it introduce, I mean we have R2 already and everyone who has held that position never plays it due to there not being a lot to do.

[Cutlaw]

Uhm, I don't know about that person, but I asked some people about it, haven't sent any links or something like that, and they think that it would be great to be a droid, and I haven't seen a droid being used in an event, passive or not passive, except the CIS and the bad guys, It will bring more diversity on the server, not just clones and naval on the ship, but actual diversity, people will roleplay with their astromechs, like helping GM repair a skygate, helping jedi/ clones to prepare their ships, doing ER routines, keeping the ship's system on and running, all around helping everyone. It may  introduce a whole new level of gamemaster ingenuity or maybe even an ordinary trooper may start roleplaying with an astromech, I see them as actually doing something for the people on the server, not for themselves and just doing what they want. It won't hurt if we try it at least, but lets not consider being inactive on the job, as it may be IRL stuff and something like that, or just bored of being astromechs, there will be almost always people who would like to try it and see the experience. I think the R2s are inactive, due to IRL stuff/getting bored, or just that events do not include the roleplay for R2... and I don't know who were the people and they personality.. soo I don't know, I just want diversity on the ship

Quote

 

 

[Arroyo]

-1 It’s enough to have RD2D and C3PO. Having other people as droids can just be mingy. Also this can ruin events with people as droids.

[Cutlaw]

I explained with the replies that the minginess can be controlled and how would it ruin an event? Also we don't have them.... they arent active or anything. Okay i understand taht both of you -1, because it can be mingy and stuff like that, but that controllable, staff will deal with them, and i am sure that it cannot ruin an event, if it's in good hands. About roleplay it won't bring any sorts of negative effects on the ship... I don't know why you don't trust people.. I am quite sad right now, but yeah.... your choice... bring some fun and creativity on the server, some roleplaying experience or just -1, because people will ruit everything.......
Have a great day!

Edited June 19, 2018 by Cutlaw

[Raven Stark]

+1 Sounds like a cool little roleplay job although if implemented in the server it shouldnt have a baton

[Cutlaw]

Alright, DonVikoYT thanks for that, appreciated, gonna remove the stunstick from there

Have a great day!

[Conrad]

+1

[IKE]

1 hour ago, Cutlaw said:

Uhm, I don't know about that person, but I asked some people about it, haven't sent any links or something like that, and they think that it would be great to be a droid, and I haven't seen a droid being used in an event, passive or not passive, except the CIS and the bad guys, It will bring more diversity on the server, not just clones and naval on the ship, but actual diversity, people will roleplay with their astromechs, like helping GM repair a skygate, helping jedi/ clones to prepare their ships, doing ER routines, keeping the ship's system on and running, all around helping everyone. It may  introduce a whole new level of gamemaster ingenuity or maybe even an ordinary trooper may start roleplaying with an astromech, I see them as actually doing something for the people on the server, not for themselves and just doing what they want. It won't hurt if we try it at least, but lets not consider being inactive on the job, as it may be IRL stuff and something like that, or just bored of being astromechs, there will be almost always people who would like to try it and see the experience. I think the R2s are inactive, due to IRL stuff/getting bored, or just that events do not include the roleplay for R2... and I don't know who were the people and they personality.. soo I don't know, I just want diversity on the ship

 

This is the perfect example of what they could do. I would personally love to see this as it would be great for fixing skyagte like he said and ER. Maybe even TECH purposes 

[Luckyy]

+1 would be cool

[Rolenth]

Okay i think i have a stroke seeing this suggestion and I'll explain why.

In ye olden' days on icefuse, this was a thing. Most people used it for RP but the rest didn't. It was so mingey I fucking gave up and didn't continue anymore. Even if people ask for "permission" to do this, i know people will abuse it. 

So uh -1. Love the idea of having them around but LORDY the minge level will increase tenfold.

[Cutlaw]

I.. we can enforce some rules about it ;c.. We ain't Icefuse... No problem in giving it a try, you have blacklist from a job and it can be fun. No reason not to trust. Not all of us are minges, some are better minded than the minges... :C

[Cutlaw]

I mean stop thinking about the minge, just think about the roleplay, the minges can be always dealt with, they come and go.. I just don't know why you don't trust people ;/

After all we know the slogan of Synergy, it ain't ICEFUSE or some other server

Synergy Roleplay is the new hope, a place where your voice can be heard and brought to life. As a community, we work in synergy to bring the game play you enjoy day in day out.

IF WE WORK AS A COMMUNITY, NO MINGE WILL RUIN OUR ROLEPLAYING EXPERIENCE!
Do NOT think about the minges! They can be jailed/blacklisted/banned! The Astromech suggestion will not last forever, it's either accepted or denied, if we want this really and NOT think about the minges,you can voice your opinion for! I will continue saying it to everyone who doesn't read the replies.

Please consider this as an actual thing, don't think about minges!!!!

Have a great day!

Edited June 19, 2018 by Cutlaw

[Cutlaw]

Yes, yes, it's like for every battalion to have one, around 4-6 max, and it will be an application format, I will do everything, I just want it ! Would be so cool, thanks Maymays!

Have a great day! ;3

[Mike]

-1 I have flashbacks to when we had people run around as gonk or cleaning droids

[Cutlaw]

I just said in the replies.. man.... and what's the problem about it? It's going to be 4-6 droids max... read the replies :C :C::C :C :C

Edited June 19, 2018 by Cutlaw

[Nade Jones]

5 minutes ago, Cutlaw said:

I just said in the replies.. man.... and what's the problem about it? It's going to be 4-6 droids max... read the replies :C :C::C :C :C

Most people don't read the replies

[Arroyo]

23 minutes ago, Mike said:

-1 I have flashbacks to when we had people run around as gonk or cleaning droids

you just gave me flashbacks of those times

[Banjans]

I am remembering the slave droid 187th had now. I don’t see this working -1. 

[BadDog]

+1 If you have a max of 4-5 and get the right people into them it could work 

[Sock Monkey]

36 minutes ago, Cutlaw said:

it's like for every battalion to have one

Having astromechs like everyone has said can be mingy and sure we can stop it. but there is also just a layer of absolute cringe, especially if there are battalion astromechs ugghhhh. In some cases already R2 gets either worshiped as a God and they all follow him around or they shun him from the bunks (501st) and he just sits out there making astromech noises, which just makes for absolutely terrible RP (And thats only one Astromech who roams about the ship barley cause he is inactive to the job which means more astromechs would make it even worse). 

When people run around as droids there is a thought that they can be goofy, where they are not breaking any rules or doing anything necessarily wrong but they are just annoying and then they get really annoying. This becomes a conundrum as there is nothing we can do to stop it and we just have to accept it (annoying Astromechs) because there is technically no rules being broken.

I get how it will enhance RP and sure maybe somebody could pull through and do some good RP as an Astromech, but I think if anything it should simply be an event job at the most. As when we are on the down time in the ship (defcon 6) there does not need to be astromechs zooming about and being distracting and annoying. 

There also needs to be rules that the staff would have to create, are the astromechs allowed in the restricted rooms? how can we identify a droid that is the republics vs a hostile astromech? Do astromechs hold a rank of troopers? What kind of rules should be made regarding astromechs exclusively? Who decides who becomes an Astromech? Ultimately there are just too many complications and I do not believe that a chance to have some good Rp should be the factor in weather or not we add astromechs as too much more goes into this idea.

 

-1 No matter how good the RP is or how little we focus on Astromechs it will end up just becoming annoying and stupid.

Edited June 19, 2018 by Sock Monkey
GRRR PAST EXPERIENCE

[Cutlaw]

Guys, please stop thinking about past experiences...

[Cutlaw]

I just want them in for hte roleplaying sake. It  will as you want, i just want it for people to roleplay with them! 4 will do the job!

GUYS, PLEASE DO NOT BRING UP PAST EXPERIENCES, THE PAST IS NOT IMPORTANT, NO ONE SAID THE SAME PERSON WHO MINGED WILL MINGE IN THE FUTURE. I want to have it so people can have more rp!!
It is your opinion, but stop bringing up past shenanigans.... the past is done, no one can redo it, the future is important... so many -1, i dont think we will achieve the goal, because of the past experiences in

 

Edited June 19, 2018 by Cutlaw

[BigZach]

-1 Reasons have been stated better than I could state them.

[Cutlaw]

Alright, I guess you won't trust people... I am done with trying to explain.... -1 it and have further roleplaying experience with clones and battalions

[Cutlaw]

Okay, I will stop replying as the suggestion will be denied soon. I appreciate those who +1, but people's past experience with the droids has been a nightmare and they won't allow it.

Have a great day....

[Sock Monkey]

28 minutes ago, Cutlaw said:

Guys, please stop thinking about past experiences...

 

13 minutes ago, Cutlaw said:

Alright, I guess you won't trust people. -1 it and have further roleplaying experience with clones and battalions

 

Just now, Cutlaw said:

but people's past experience with the droids has been a nightmare and they won't allow it.

Have a great day....

You're trying to close up and ignore all other arguments because REEE PAST ASTROMECH RP EXPERIENCE WAS BAD AND NOBODY SHOULD BRING IT UP REEEE. When you should be acknowledging that the argument of better Rp is not enough to convince us that more Astromech jobs need to be added. I fixed my original -1 post to not include past Rp experience, but your relpy was simply stop thinking about past experiences. You did not defend any other points I had and only focused on the one you could defend. To me its not the past experience that makes my decision and that was only a small part of my argument. You're acting like anyone who -1's and brings back a past experience is completely wrong and I believe they have the right to consider and bring up the past because adding astromechs could quickly become what they expected and just dont want to take the risk.

[Cutlaw]

I seriously did not see it, I didn't refresh my page, I am sorry that I didn't see it, but I got discouraged, all the points have been brought up and if most of you have the same points, It's true. I cannot bring anything else up in my defense, you have the arguments, I thought that we had only the negative aspects of the suggestions, but it seems that i have been misguided, or I have misjudged the whole point. I understand now everything and I will be at the mercy of the community. I was blinded by my fuss to add astromechs I didn't listen to the community. All the point were true and I was blinded by my own mind.. I have learnt my mistake.

Sorry Nade Jones,sorry Arroyo, sorry Benjans, sorry Medic, sorry Mike, sorry Maymays, sorry Bigzach, sorry Sock Monkey and sorry to everyone who had to read through that...sincerely apologising

Sorry, have a great day!

 

[WaterMelonWolf]

-1, its really not needed. Unless the person is good at TECH RP and what not,

[Metro]

-1, not needed whatsoever.

[Ragen]

I say +1

[Esitt]

I see the idea, but its truly not needed.

DENIED

//Locked

//Moved to Server Suggestions - Denied