While it is common knowledge that being on top of the Venator ATC is not fail roleplay, the situation was poorly handled on both sides here. Zyner should have brought you into a sit rather than spawning himself a baton or physgunning you 5 times. However, after being taken off the ATC you should have spoken to Zyner about it rather than ignoring him and going back on top 4 more times.
The rule needs to be updated in the document, yes. However, most people are aware you are allowed on top of the ATC.
Furthermore, this entire thread is being handled in a very unprofessional manner. Everyone here is flaming out at each other, and its not tolerated, nor is it going to get anyone anywhere.
I cannot close a staff report myself, however, I recommend this be closed with the simple statement that being on ATC is not failRP.