Egg

I dont think they should have final say but it should be weighed heavily depending on the situation, especially for higher rank positions. The application and interview should not matter as much as the feedback they get as well. If there is some shady stuff going on then the overall community feedback and review can help combat that. Overall the suggestion is on the right track to a really good idea that should be implemented at least a little bit already but with a little fine tuning and adjustment, it could actually work. What I mean is, instead of FINAL say, if the battalion is doing well and understands how it runs, it should be someone that the battalion wants and trusts to continue to improve and run the battalion properly and not some randy coming in hot with a hostile takeover for power. The second part I do not really see is needed because the XO doesn't always want to run for the BCMD spot, the added responsibility may be something that they just do not want to take on and someone else may be trained and just as ready to take it. Overall, +1 for a little bit of a tweaked number 1 and a -1 for part 2.

you called one of my commanders plain and boring. I will cut you. You also betrayed my trust and made me look like a moron because I defended you when you originally left 501st and got called out for MassRDMing. Honestly, it is just a gmod server and nothing even matters. You have gotten everything that was deserved of you and its really just time to stop, actually though, please. Anyways, there really isn't anything that you could say that would cause me to +1 this because of things that you did to me, my friends, and my battalion. Goodbye and please just... stop.

Just get good? -1

+1 Might be a retard sometimes but he isn't a complete idiot

3rd time's the charm? +1 Forreal tho, this isnt gonna happen

First off, I would like to keep this ship a no vape zone and this is not the way to do it. Memes aside. Next, unless they have been changed, they reset the health of event jobs and everyone that is near them when they detonate. This causes issues by abusing them and you are able to essentially ruin an event with 1 throw. This is not something that is needed by every medic. Having it SOBDE only doesn't make a whole lot of sense but looking at it, it is really not needed and can cause a lot of issues. -1

+1 to say it was close. Actually though, that's how med rp works.

I would say -1 because you can give the job a toolgun. Having a toolgun can break the server in multiple ways and people abuse the jobs more often than you would think and giving those people a toolgun would cause more harm to the server instead of providing help to the Gamemasters.

So, on the main server, the ban is supposed to be 7 days. When someone is not able to be banned, they ban them for as long as they can and then put in a ban extension request in the staff discord and it is then handled by the proper people. If you are talking about in TS, this issue has come up before. If you are in a private channel and the channel rules allow it, then go nuts. From what I have read here, you also want to punish people for not actually doing anything and that is not really fair. -1 for being unnecessary and also people are already punished for this.

I just want to point out that nowhere in the server suggestion it says demote sock, or devalue anything he has done. Everyone just assumes that it is when in reality it is to make ct's not be able to be promoted because that is how it is supposed to be. You have to be in a battalion to be promoted. Sock mentioned that you have to be a high rank to attend ARC training, which if I am not mistaken isn't entirely true, you just have to be cleared by a commanding officer or ARCL in your battalion. The initial suggestion is being blown out of proportion to the point where keyboard commandos are just spewing straight autism onto their screen.

+1 I thought this was a thing but a few people have proven otherwise

There really is no reason for this people usually go afk in a corner or in a chair on 2nd floor lobby. There isnt really a way to police this and if someone is afk blocking a hallway, go over or around them. -1

I don't know if you actually did any fact checking before posting this but the Dual DC-17s just got buffed to 50 damage a shot, Westar does 58 damage with a 50 round mag and your battalion specific DC-15A, which EVERYONE has, does 50 damage. The entire battalion also has buffed health which means that you have multiple buffs as apposed to everyone else having one. This way of making buffs would be difficult but would all around make battalions good at what your battalion is supposed to do. +1

Bug Type (server/forum): Server Severity level (1-3):1 or 2 Evidence (if you can): Description of the bug:They spawn with a scoutblaster in their loadout and they are not supposed to have one. How can we recreate it: Spawn on the ARC job @Firat I am reporting it because the gun is a SCOUTblaster and this is not a scout. It is ARC there are few classes that are supposed to have it and this is not one of them.

-1 If you want this, kill off fives and make cyborg echo. Also, kill off hardcase and tup because they would have been killed. Sound like a good trade?

The weapons that jer troopers have usually varies by battalion. Also, I dont want this class in my battalion. Jet troopers in 41st have the scopes dc15a because it makes sense for how they are used in my battalion, having every battalion have this would not make sense and is just not needed.

Yes, all weapon packs are huge but 239.776MB for a total of 9 weapons and the developer said that there are not going to be any new ones for clone, doesn't seem worth for what you're getting. It really isn't improving RP in any way that I can tell because we already have the weapons on the server, yes they look better but they would not fit in with the playermodels and things we currently have. There are a lot of other things we can do with this space and also there is a lot of negative feedback already on this suggestion and I am going to add onto that pile with a -1 with the reasons of massive space being taken up, does not fit in with current models and other weapons, and just being unnecessary.

-1

+1 Barriss's medpack was removed when King David's system came out but when we removed it, the medpack was never put back even though all the other healers got theirs back.

-1 for the reason of, not all battalions have a support trooper. The purpose of 41st support troopers are, they are the AT RT driver class for the battalion do they provide support with the at rts and scout ahead and provide vehicle cover. Idk what gm support is supposed to do other than just be a full out support. Adding support trooper to every battalion is not necessary.

There is no timetable for when that is coming out and the "just because it is happening EVENTUALLY" excuse for having new stuff sucks. He put a solid amount of time and effort into making a pretty decent model that can be used as a placeholder for when the time comes for gideon and Kyle to come along and go over them. PS: I just realized i never dropped a +1

What makes them special is their job and custom armor, not weapons. Giving custom weapons to named characters will just make them overpowered and other battalions have more than others and some just have none. Battalions use their lore characters in different ways and giving them better weapons than everyone else would not be fair to the rest of the server -1

that looks much better @CBlake

First off. -1 for not following format. Next, I would like to fact check some of your accusations and evidence. Not everyone has a pilot job, in fact, most battalions don't have a pilot job and giving an entire squad to a battalion is just unnecessary. Also with the amount of times that you are actually allowed to fly, it would be pointless.

I want to +1 but the flames really put me off of the model as a whole. The blue cross seems to be a bit out of place because it makes the lower torso just completely open and the upper torso far too cluttered. Also the patch on the chest adds to the clutter. Maybe put it on the shoulder or remove it as a whole. If you changed the cross on the chest to include the rest of the chestplate like continuing the line on the helmet to be a long triangle down the chest or just having it go down to the mid breastplate and split off into 2 separate lines. That is just my design input and I am going to stay neutral on this.