So lets look at the pictures..
A. SO with a shield? Admin abuse of power because well, he didnt need a shield and shouldnt have it.
B. In pictures you notice him with a shield and Natsu with 0 Shield and half health. Odd huh?
C. In the last picture. It shows natsu dead. Well, how did he die? And why would he lie? I know Natsu. And i know he wouldnt lie about this situation.
With that being said, this has my +1.
Reason:
1. He cant give us a straight answer
2. The proof explains enough.