TheGoodOatmeal

I’m out of the loop a lil bit can someone say what happened that was deemed unfit?

+1 Welder’s union

+1 good luck

Changing to a -1 after reading over the other responses. From what everyone is saying this is kind of just unnecessary.

+1 has been an issue since June

-1 I’ve been told by your past that you really don’t follow through. I’ve heard from people inside 21st you didn’t do much as REGL or ARFL. Then when I asked ya about it you said “you got bored.” We don’t want another burnt out bacara

+1 comdupyoon

+1 Has been XO the past weeks and is basically running the bat.

Whole point of a BCMD app is to explain to people why you should be the BCMD, ie you tell them how you will fix issues in the batt and how you will make the batt better. You stated previously your idea with SC and legacy even though many members of the batt directly oppose it. You have only been a jedi in the 21st and, when I played throughout August, saw you on rarely. I would only see you join deployments. You just got your trooper back, and like I previously said, Trooper and Jedi are very very different atleast in 21st. And I saw you do very little for the jedi's. The reason I showed the discord pictures is because you said you got your "KU Maj" tag back on day one. You got your jedi tags and such, those are very different things. But you did not get your KU Maj tags back until yesterday, which is like 2 months since you've returned according to yourself.

Just a few things 1- You did not get you KU MAJ Tag back on day one. You got it like yesterday, I SS and showed the date for proof. If youre talking about legacy, that technically doesnt count since all legacy members will always be apart of those units unless they get removed. You have been chilling on your Jedi 2- The last part is mostly false. When you say 2 months I am going to assume you mean 7-27>9-27. Fenrir was BCMD until 8/7, Claw was Keller After Fenrir left, Claw put his app up and was the XO until his app got accepted 8/14 and became Bacara 8/15ish. As soon as he became Bacara, he made Darren Keller. (Darren is Charger) Then Claw resigned 9/6 Which led Jaydon to put up an app, and he voided it so he could write a better one. Then Butters did the same, same result. Then Keller/Darren resigned 9/21 So your point about there "not being a Bacara OR a keller in the past 2 months" Is completely false. We havent had one in 3 weeks, but Jaydon has been basically unofficially running the battalion. We also havent had a Keller in only 6 days. 3- No one believes that " legacy members are obsolete in their ability to be successful" What is meant by that is that they if they have not been on the server in a while, they should get acclimated to the new changes before getting their hands deep into a leadership position. 21st has changed alot the past 2ish years and it is no longer the marines, SO also. Being a Jedi is a lot different then being a trooper, especially 21st. There is tons of trainings/tryouts you need to know that only come with time. What I am trying to say is yes, you got the leadership down, but play for like 2 weeks atleast as a 21st Trooper consistently and consider if you want to take on a 3 month BCMD term afterwards. Because when I played all the way up until the end of August, I rarely saw you on just on for a few deployments and such. Making SO a more exclusive sub unit is not a good idea. Considering id say 4/5 new members join for SO, atleast as of recently. This has not been implemented ever since the merger because of this. Forcing new people to join GM, just to go to SO seems super extra considering GM is more of a frontal attack and marines while SO is more stealthy and recon. These are complete opposites and should remain seperate. Which is why this progression makes no sense. GM to KU makes sense because KU picks the best GMs. This should be the same with SO and SC. SC should not become a legacy job and should be exclusively for the ARC job. If there is no SC then SO would not be as rewarding to join and people would then join GM as a result. You should keep a balance and make it even whatever side you go. NC is the trial phase of the 21st, you do your trainings and wait you 3 days to see if you can make the cut. Example: NC> GM or SO. GM > GM Regs SO > SO Regs SO > SC. GM > KU. Your issue with the f4 menu drop down thing does not really make sense. Considering, up until the beginning of Summer 2020, KU also did not have their own drop down box and was just a different model on the GM Troopers. It would seem hypocritical of you to make SC legacy only just cause it doesnt have its own drop down menu when KU was literally in the same boat prior to Summer 2020. Again, this isnt a marine only batt now, SO is a big part of it too. I think the best look would be to run a batt in the best interest of SO and GM to avoid bias. For example, each side has their own tryouts for the basic branch (GM and SO) and a tryout for their elite branches and other regs (KU SC). 1- You say you understand the change in times but are directly going against that by actively trying to hinder SO's growth. You first want to make everyone join GM THEN have to join SO or KU, which like I said previously makes no sense. It is like having someone join the 501st just to then tryout for the 41st. They are two different units and should be treated as such, not mixed to boost GM numbers. You also want to make SC, SO's elite unit, Legacy only. This will greatly affect anyone interested in SO because if they realize there is no elite unit on SO side they will just try to go for GMs elite unit. I dont understand why you are making SC a legacy only position but not KU, it just does not make sense. Neither of them should be. You are still acting like the 21st is just comprised of GM, and need to be more receptive to SO. 2- Well when it comes to a BCMD app, people want to know how you will fix the issues of 21st. That is why they want to know the issues. 3- You do not even have a plan to fix the issues because you are still learning them. This is a HUGE red flag, how can we expect someone to lead the 21st when they still do not fully understand what is wrong and what the 21st is about. This is why you need to spend a few weeks in the modern 21st, to understand what really is the issue. Even though you stated you were watching over the 21st on your jedi, you clearly were not doing it enough if you are not aware enough of our current issues to formulate a plan.

I mean, I just saw you were given your 21st officer tags back. You should play and be consistently active for the next 1-2ish weeks so people know you can handle it then re apply. Because you’ve been Bacara and Keller lots of times but like people have brought up the server has changed. It’s not really all marine oriented now, in fact, the past few months SO has been carrying the battalion. We also have no Keller or no GM CMD as of now. Why don’t you try doing those again to see if you really still wanna be a BCMD. Cause you JUST got your tags back for trooper and I feel this is too big of a leap. See about progressing instead of jumping straight to it. I feel If anyone else were to also apply with these conditions it would get mostly negatives, but you are well known throughout the old community. So that is why I suggest you play consistently the next few weeks just to get a taste of modern synergy, so you know how the new 21st works in terms of tryouts, trainings, intel, and everything else. Overall +1 as of now just be more active.

I agree with Comics on the length however. Many older players can vouche for how well you did but I feel you should explain to people that don’t know you as much why you should be it. And i haven’t seen much of you on (when I played in august, not as of recent) 21st has changed a lot too

+1 who is zest i only know spectronk

I think “make 21st good” was a great way to put it! He isn’t the option we want, but the option we neeed +1000000000000000

Snow map or endor +1 or whatever anyone agrees on

I initially supported this because I don’t think any of our other officers weren’t ready/didn’t want to apply, but I am going to have to change my mind after reading some of these posts and looking into it more sorry man. You joined the battalion 8/2 you have been on a total of 3 LOAs totaling 16 days total of LOA time. You’ve been in the batt for 37 days total which means you have only been in this batt for 3 weeks active time at most. I think you should give it another month and get some more experience before jumping into a BCMD position too early. Sorry butters -1 PS: We don’t need a Bacara immediately, only exception I would Make is jaydon since he was essentially Claws Xo even though he didn’t have the rank. Give it some time And for all the people who were wondering, Jaydon was suppose to be the one who replaced Claw due to him practically running the batt without the title, but he voided his app.

+1 Make the 21st Discord Layout great again

Yes the app was not worded the best, but the content still remains true. most of the 21st is in agreement that he is inactive. People from different time zones in our batt are agreeing to that, which I think is lots of evidence but like Number said, he can record a six hour video and load up a hardrive for that sake if you believe it is really necessary. I want to know what you thought was unprofessional by our responses, all of my responses I was just trying to interject and respond to people who had different views from me. I wasn’t trying to be like “you idiot you don’t know more cause you ain’t in 21st.” To add on to that, most of their -1s I thought they misunderstood so I wanted to correct them with what I thought was right. Most of the people who -1 were outside of the 21st, meaning they don’t see Claw as often as we do. Isn’t is slightly concerning that all of the active 21st is in support of this report? That means it isn’t just a one man grudge, this is a battalion wide problem. Claw has talked to me in DMs confirming/hinting at him reading this. He still hasn’t responded and I don’t think he will. Which just plays into his communication issue. I’d love for him to defend himself here, but he isn’t which is just making himself a worse

I said this above, but I feel like this is little bit is sort of directed at me. I made numerous suggestions in what I felt would help better the 21st, most of the ones I made he would -1/deny them and never gave me a reason. Most of the time when a suggestion is denied they’ll tell ya why too. That is one of the main things that drove me to leave, also pair that with the fact he doesn’t communicate. He might respond to you pretty quickly, that doesn’t mean he does it to the whole 21st, cause as of recent he has been less and less talkative and is almost ghosting. Most of the time I try to propose things to “fix” the battalion like you said they get shut down with no responses, it’s always happened. And I, along with most of the batt besides like one other person, did not know he was actively changing legacy rules or anything else because he doesn’t consult us. So the reason no one has really told him “why did you do this” is because he does it and keeps it to himself, making it very hard to know.

To add to this point: before Claw was BCMD, he was always on and very active and this sudden change of inactivity is very odd because he didn’t put any LOA/ROA. It’s just him loosing interest playing other games and ignoring people in the 21st. Like I stated before, he is ghosting this post and avoiding response

As you probably see, most of the active 21st is supporting this commander report, which means that all of his claims have some backup/support because If they were false claims the 21st would -1 saying it isn’t true. So this is plenty reliable

I know he has viewed this because he has messaged me in discord about the subject, but he isn’t responding which is the issue. And about the bigger picture, if we can remove a Bacara and replace it with an active/more communicative One I see this as a win. Our numbers are fine right now, but our only problem is our BCMD. Claw has had his chance and I don’t think he is going to redeem himself at all considering he isn’t responding to this at all, he’s proven to be inactive and unfit. This is for the better. This was not sudden at all, more of a gradual decline. Claw was pretty active at the start of his term. THEN, he started to hide in his Officer channel and hide in the bunks AFKing doing nothing for the past weeks of his term, tabbing out playing other games when he told us not to do that. He also barely responds in our own 21st discord, so we never know his actions/plans. This was not sudden at all. The fact of the matter is that this isn’t a one person grudge, literally all of 21st is agreeing with this, which shows you this is an issue What are you talking about? Number was not the one who made the resignation, Midge did, and number was using it in the report because it shows what Claw truly has done, not much. And if you saw the actual resignation Midge pinged the 21st Troopers because he saying goodbye to them instead of separate pings cause there was too many. I’m not sure why everything is drama now, he was simply stating his opinion about a person in the battalion. Everything he said was true. Not like he was calling him an ass or nerd or any thing. Simply stating what Claw is doing wrong. Sure it was harsh, but he is an inactive BCMD and has slowly lost interest and activity, I think this was necessary.

Why everytime something like this arises there is a powerplay accusation. Number WAS Bacara while back and he has already. This report was made for the betterment of the battalion, not for some cheap powerplay. Notice how MOST of the 21st is agreeing with this report, it should say something.

Can you see the responses by the other 21st members? Especially the ones that are DU transfers, they are in support of this CMD report which shows they are staying not because of Claw, but for some other reasoning like the classes etc. Even one of the DU transfers resigned today due to part of it being “high command issues.” Point is, they ain’t here for claw

If you have ever dmed claw or messaged him, you never get very detailed responses, you’ll get responses like “yes” “no” and not much else. Pair that with the fact he is AFK most of the time in TS, it is hard to communicate with him