Leaderboard

-1 Bringing back foxtrot to 212th or SOBDE will do nothing but cause a tear in the server and create fights This is coming from a former SOBDE BCMD who tried to get foxtrot readded. It will not end will and the rift will be permanent no matter who gets foxtrot.

Just to set the record straight, Foxtrot was an active, stable subunit in 212th for over a year and a half, and it wasn't removed from 212th for any negative reasons on our part. I can somewhat understand the argument of Foxtrot being a stepping stone to SOBDE, and while I can't say with 100% certainty that people didn't see it that same way, I can say that most of the longtime members did not see it that way. Many of the long term members of Foxtrot never went to SOBDE, or any other battalion. Two Gregor's and One normal Foxtrot trooper eventually become Commander Cody, and another Gregor ended up as Attack Regimental, with many of them returning months later to go back to Foxtrot. Some of these old long term members have even expressed an interest in helping the subunit if it does return to the 212th, which to me, speaks volumes as to what the subunit meant to us as a battalion. I know there isn't much I can say to change your mind about this, I just want you to understand how much work was put into Foxtrot the first time to make sure it was a sustainable and long-term addition to the battalion, and that mindset hasn't change an iota in the years since. I don't want to clog the thread with a consistent back and forth, though if you're interested in talking further, please DM me, as I always enjoy regaling people with the history of 212th!

I see what you mean, but I disagree. Worst case scenario, you've just poured tons of battalion resources into a failed project. The point I am making is that, while there is initial interest in the squad, it will not be sustainable at all and will not last. People have always used Foxtrot as a transition squad, and I don't think it will be used any differently now. It will gradually wind down to be how it has always been, a squad filled with people who want RC but are held back because of love for 212th or just general insufficiency for SO BDE. I understand what you're saying about GC, but I don't think it applies to Foxtrot. As you said, Ghost Company receives the extra lore names and the prestige within 212th, and those who join it are the most elite troopers that 212th has to offer. I don't believe that this mentality that people have with Ghost Company will apply to Foxtrot. People will view it as a weird SO BDE junior rather than a 212th elite squad. The mentality of Foxtrot was never and has never been, as a 212th Elite RC Squad. It has been as a 212th/SOBDE Hybrid amalgamation that people used as a tool to have an SO BDE experience mixed with a traditional battalion. Foxtrot is unsustainable in the long run. The addition of it now is pointless, and I can see it being removed again. That is the argument I have against Foxtrot, and from my original message. The squad will run fine, but not for long. It will have interest, but not for long. It will have members who want to be in it for it, and are active in it, but not for long. I hope this clarifies things. If you'd like to keep talking about these things, let me know! I have good experience.

this post is very funny to watch and I genuinely don't know which side has more people chiming in when their opinion doesn't matter ig -1 I really don't think 212th having more stuff matters in the long run but I just like seeing Finn get mad

Korty worty is just jealous

+1 212th needs more content

Yeah I think you and I are gonna just agree to disagree here. As someone who's been in 212th for practically a year I'm confident with my battalion, their dedication, and MY dedication to make sure this runs well. I understand you have a lot of experience on this server in the past and I respect that. I do think my first hand experience with 212th as of right now is enough to base my argument off of.

-1 because @NissanMikli is Walon right now

+1 Bringing back foxtrot brings that little bit more Roleplay opportunities into 212th within game keeping members who are here for a more serious roleplay time interested now that might be selfish to say coming from a former 212th BCMD but it's within game so the Roleplay opportunities will reach many different people within the server and if foxtrot is done the right way it will bring in a more serious roleplay experience from a battalion point of view having another sub unit like this will give another active member of the battalion a chance to lead a subunit and show his/hers leadership skills and also improve them as sub leads within a battalion should be the next in line to become battalion commander so it gives another person a chance to show and improve on his/hers leadership skills what I think is key bring in a more serious jedi position to the battalion what will benefit the jedi order letting someone who enjoys a more serious role have one being a knight or even padawan 1 on 1 advanced trainings 0r Group Training (Some Examples) if done right and keep the squad very hands on the server to set up trainings and even events will impact not just the battalion but keep the server interested as well the squad working together to come up with stuff well that just sounds like a lot of fun Recon Defence Sharp Shooting Stealth Target Marking - Search and Destroy 1 Lifes Capture and Rescue Stranded on unknowing place/planet Escaping CIS prison Lost behind enemy front lines Outpost living and Defence Stealing CIS future plans I overall thing this yes this will Benefit the battalion a lot but will also benefit the server if the squad is done right so i do not thing 212th are being selfish by asking for another sub unit as under Kaiser and the next Battalion commanders that this sub unit will be ran the right way to not just benefit the 212th but the full server so i believe 212th should have a chance to prove that, all we are asking for is a chance to prove we are moving into the future and we can do it