The problem I see is the idea of recruiting on this server, people trying to be the biggest battalion all the time and it results in people how are either not properly trained on the rules or just there to minge getting into battalion cause the second they walk out the CT bunks doors they get pulled into a tryout. With this concept a minge has to waste a little more time doing the tryouts, but when you join a battalion no matter the rank, you instantly get that notoriety of NOT being a CT and in their eyes makes it easier to get away with stuff.
Also I already believe that the arrest time of 15 minutes is way too long anyways. When a new trooper gets on goes into an area he is not supposed to or accidentally talks during db and gets arrested for that absurd amount of time deters them from wanting to play on the server, even if they didn't know they were breaking a rule and was just enjoying the server. This problem is that we assume that all new CTs understand everything after TR training which is not true. When i first played clone wars RP I had no idea what the hell PTS mean't, obviously overtime I figured it out, but when a CT cheers for someone in db with their mic or cant sit down cause they are not really sure how they get swarmed by CG and other members who get mad and frustrated at them which I find unfair. Overall a better understanding of the new players is more important and being more sympathetic to their undeveloped knowledge to the rules should be kept in mind, the arrest time for everyone should be minimized and if someone actually has no intent to rp, there should be stricter repercussions by staff. Because punishing the lacked knowledge of a new player should not occur as it easily drives out players as well as makes older players upset for getting arrested for 15 minutes for stupid reasons. I understand where this post is getting at, but its not hitting the core problem of the CGs and the arrest procedures, which is why I dont see it as fixing anything long term, and will just make CG have to do more pointless stuff that eventually will either become unimportant or commanders would deem unreliable as CGs is few cases happen to arrest people for improper reasons, or high ranks of other battalions who dont like people could just call AOS on them and it would get logged and get them possibly demoted without a proper defense.
-1