Leaderboard

Name: Logic | Gree This is not a normal suggestion so please read it all Joah has recently announced that 187th will be added back and a battalion will get removed. Normally this would be fine, but he took a community vote, because this isn’t icefuse, so he gave the community a voice, at my current time typing this there is 82 yesses in that poll. Now yes that IS a substantial amount, until you look at the Nos. One Hundred and Twenty. That is almost 150% the amount of yesses. And yet, joah took this vote and said fuck it we’re adding it back. Because “By the players, For the players” why to add it back: I’ve looked through alot of the comments and heres what I saw. -Makes a small amount of players happy -Replaces a struggling battalion -brings back some old members thats basically what I saw. Why NOT to add it back: -Because the players don’t want it back -Because it will empty out members from battalions that are struggling or recovering. Making them all in the same position as the battalion that is getting removed -It has 2 lines of Lore -It will destroy 2nd AC because they lose their uniqueness -our recruits are already spread so thin that the upset balance 187th will make can destroy the future for other battalions -Because there is other ways to fix the issues in the struggling battalion that you plan on removing other than complete removal. -The people who wanted to add it back had no valid reason other than “I miss it” This community is made by the players, for the players, so listen to the players, please

Name: Logic | Gree This is not a normal suggestion so please read it all Joah has recently announced that 187th will be added back and a battalion will get removed. Normally this would be fine, but he took a community vote, because this isn’t icefuse, so he gave the community a voice, at my current time typing this there is 82 yesses in that poll. Now yes that IS a substantial amount, until you look at the Nos. One Hundred and Twenty. That is almost 150% the amount of yesses. And yet, joah took this vote and said fuck it we’re adding it back. Because “By the players, For the players” why to add it back: I’ve looked through alot of the comments and heres what I saw. -Makes a small amount of players happy -Replaces a struggling battalion -brings back some old members thats basically what I saw. Why NOT to add it back: -Because the players don’t want it back -Because it will empty out members from battalions that are struggling or recovering. Making them all in the same position as the battalion that is getting removed -It has 2 lines of Lore -It will destroy 2nd AC because they lose their uniqueness -our recruits are already spread so thin that the upset balance 187th will make can destroy the future for other battalions -Because there is other ways to fix the issues in the struggling battalion that you plan on removing other than complete removal. -The people who wanted to add it back had no valid reason other than “I miss it” This community is made by the players, for the players, so listen to the players, please 22 minutes and it had 10+ +1s, I definitely say let us speak. Also 2ndAC Is far from dead lmfao

Logic, I've already made the statement, that nothing is going to change this. It is happening, times change. I've already committed $300+ Into their creation and return. 2AB, is already essentially none-existant, so that argument has already gone out the window. For all your arguments that are being made, we might as well not have given 327th a chance at all and never re-added them. Also, for "Struggling battalions" There are only 2. and that's for a very good reason. I'm not going to turn this into a public roast fest for those individuals. But only 2 commanders are a serious issue right now and refuse to fix their attitude for the betterment of their battalions. The rest are perfectly fine. "This community is made by the players, for the players, so listen to the players, please" I love how this line is your last defense and everyone's last defense. The community is made by the players and for the players. but that does not mean that I allow the community to make 100% of the decisions, otherwise, you'd all be at founder meetings/etc. I have no intention of always going with 100% of the majority, sometimes the minority will win. ~ In this case, the Minority, is 80+ People, which is typically quadruple the suggestion about. <-- Again a number that is nothing to scoff at. When you say. "Only" some players" I can tell you right now 12 in specific have returned directly for the 187th return. 5 of which applied for staff. For when you to state that it's going to hurt others? It seems like it makes up where you lack in care. If you care about your battalion and they care about you, they will remain for you. Just as they did for me in the 501st when I was able to get 50+ Players online by actively creating a stimulating environment. Stop making excuses for why battalions are dead, and do something about it. This is denied and will be denied until we see how 187th physically does. I'm not going to kill something that hasn't even been given a chance to breathe. It's time to sit down and rest my son. DENIED PS: For those who are overly worked up about a battalion. There is a sun outside, please go see it.

+1 might as well have nightmare bring back his shitty mic too, consider it a package deal

+1 if you can somehow make private ts channels still work with public chat. -1 if not. I'm not giving up having both public and private chat.

Void this. my computer decied to turn off before i could edit it

Valhalla welcomes you, I will be speaking with you when you get online. -Locked-

This is indeed interesting I remember a couple times since the beginning this has happened and yea it will be great for the first couple of months then dies off and the server in the most part was worse off after the change. I will just say this hopefully this is looked at by all angles instead of singular reasons is all I am going to say. The migration seen a lot of greatness in the beginning but things are slowly coming full circle wait and see if another circle is made. Polls in the past have made the decision but some how implementations are made in another direction lets just see how this goes. Remember to many choices are a bad thing.

I agree with Logic, why add another battalion in when everyine else is having a slow recruitment time. There just isnt as many new people coming to the server to just add another battalion. Last time one was added EVERY battalion was hit very hard for months. Fix the rp problems on your rp server before adding someone in and saying its going to help make things better

I'm Neutral on this, Why not back back RM? Joah do make some bad decisions but its the best for the server.

Name: Wagner/Warthog Suggestion: Add a standard issue Pilot weapon that is useful on the ground the DC17 is useless in PVP and PVE. In lore republic Pilots are given the DN bolt caster which was hella powerful. Give pilots an explosive device as they had timebombs in lore. Implementation: Add a weapon to the pilot job with a slow firerate but a lot of damage. Since there isnt a weapon that you can charge up so it does more damage i believe just implement a high power blaster rifle so pilots aren’t completely useless on ground. Give pilots an explosive device since they had time bombs in lore. Lore: Most people that think that the DN bol caster sounds familiar is because it was in the Old Battlefront 2 game. You could have it in youre loadout as a pilot. https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Clone_trooper_pilot/Legends https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/"DN_bolt_caster"_plasma_disruptor https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Time_bomb

Add or Change: Adding Yarael Poof to the server because since the 187th are coming back Poof should come back too. Poof can add fun to the server fun and many roleplay like his illusion effect. Poof can also be a huge boost of players for a battalion if he joins one. Job: Jedi Master Yarael Poof Model: models/cultist_kun/sw/yarael_poof.mdl Weapons: Jedi Master Saber Other: None

Name: CrazyFastNight Suggestion: Implement a new way of talking such as GSpeak Implementation: So this May sound dumb but listen, we all know Gmod audio sucks and I’d you think it doesn’t you are lying to yourself. Delays ruin roleplay, audio levels hurt ears let’s fix it. I have been playing a lot of arma with my boy Max lately, and they use Task Force radio but that doesn’t work for Gmod. But there is a thing called GSpeak where we all are in the same channel of teamspeak and it detects when someone is near you. If you want to talk to your battalion, we can implement radios. Lore: Mouths were made to speak Workshop content if applicable: https://www.gmodstore.com/market/view/1656 https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=635535045 (If no workshop content, suggest a developer or put "Require Development")

-1 just because of a loreless fucking purple leigon so we are adding back a dead lore character?

-1 No... Just. No.

lore doesnt exist here

+1 only if you give it to nightmare

-1 While lore kinda takes a back seat on the server Poof died before the Clone Wars even started (if you follow Legends at least). He's long dead. Sorry.

If you took ten seconds to look at what he linked you would see that it literally uses team speak as in game voice. It basically allows us to use teamspeak for everything it makes our life easier. There is literally nothing to confirm what you've stated anywhere. Lastly this gets a massive +1 from me. This can lead to increased RP where battalions have to actually use radio comms, similarly to task force radio in arma 3. Lastly it provides the way better audio quality of teamspeak vs garrys mod shit voice comms.

-1, I know where you're coming from but you've also gotta keep in mind this helps us catch minges or aresst's who are hiding somewhere.

lol wut

I mean. It's you vs the 100+ no votes.

Is that what happened with 327th when we returned them?

I agree i think if we add any new batts anyway is to add a different batt that is more unique and never has been on the server before but it is what is 0.o

+1, players chose

+1. 187th is a useless addition that's only here to appease the older players and friends of the owner. I see no reason why we should bring it back. It's gonna kill other battalions just for it to die itself. And that's the best scenario I can see happening.

Jetpacks arent necessarily always used to "get up to elevated surfaces to initiate far ranged combat". You might use them that way. But that doesnt mean everyone else has to. The 212th being an attack battalion has to push the enemy. Making it far more likely that we will be in close quarters combat. Jetpacks can be used to get closer to the enemy leagues quicker than a normal trooper. That paired with the fact that 2ndAC are airborne means that they will be paratrooping in some cases right on top of the enemy makes it useful for them to have a CQC weapon. The shotgun is a weapon ideal for that role. If someone could come up with a reason besides "I dont use my jetpack that way so you dont get to" that would be helpful. Or even better provide some sort of weapon to fit your standard of long range combat (and no not the sniper because the reason this is being made in the first place is because we dont have a sniper class anymore). +1

He already reported his own content as well. You don't need to make a report on yourself bro You got the warning point but ya just need to chill

be careful what you wish for

This can't be real. Uh. Good meme. DENIED //Locked //Moved to Server Suggestions - Denied

+1 Well, it has come to my attention that although, Poof would be dead. The current state of peoples +1's want him back. Although if Poof is to return again I believe that Nightmare be the only 1 to run for it if not be one of the only.